Fair or not, BCS makes its own rules

Published: Tuesday, May 19, 2009 11:29 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

It's fine by me that Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, Mountain West Conference commissioner Craig Thompson and Sen. Orrin Hatch plan to keep pressuring the Bowl Championship Series, in hopes of rearranging the national college football landscape.

But that doesn't mean I think it's going to work.

Are the self-satisfied big conferences really going to slap themselves and say, "This isn't fair; what were we thinking?"

Look at it this way: Are pharmaceutical companies going to say, "We were making too much money; let's lower our prices"?

Conferences and bowl games are in it for the money, not to sing "Share the Land."

Thompson has been at the forefront of the battle to win access for teams like those from the MWC. If you haven't followed the controversy, here's the Cliff's Notes: six FBS (formerly Division I-A) conferences get a chance to play for the national championship, while five don't. Additionally, if a smaller conference school like Utah or BYU gets to a lucrative BCS bowl, it has to share $9.5 million with 51 similar schools. Meanwhile, big conference teams get $18 million to share with just 9 to 11 of their peers.

I'm no accountant, but even I can figure out that's not a good deal for the little guys.

Story continues below

Thompson has that figured out, too. Last month, he met with BCS conference commissioners, proposing an eight-team playoff. He also appeared at congressional hearings to explain why he thinks that should happen.

A lot of congresspeople seemed to agree the current system isn't fair.

Well, neither is male pattern baldness, but it continues.

Meanwhile, the BCS big shots, like coordinator John Swofford, patiently and condescendingly explained that it's all about the marketplace.

In that, he wasn't lying. The current BCS conferences — the Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-10, Southeastern, Atlantic Coast and Big East — comprise the bulk of the viewing audience. A fifth-place Michigan will outdraw a first-place Hawaii in TV ratings any day.

Swofford and others agreed to take Thompson's playoff suggestions back to their summer meetings for careful consideration. Right. And Hillary's going to join the Young Republicans.

Why would a conference that can split $18 million 10 ways decide to split it 61 ways? With most college athletic departments losing money, why voluntarily earn less? Why give Boise State or Utah the chance to prove they're No. 1 when you don't have to?

The plan for the BCS right now is obvious: ride this out. If it can stall a few more months, and no spoiler like Utah or Boise State emerges, it can say it's vindicated.

Maybe the whole thing will blow over.

Recent comments

Interesting that you point out these rules for inclusion. When do...

Re: kiyoshige | May 21, 2009 at 2:37 p.m.

What Mr. Rock has failed to acknowledge with his glib comparisons to...

Rock is Rong | May 21, 2009 at 11:58 a.m.

Argue all you want, have congressionals, make lawsuits. MWC can have...

kiyoshige | May 21, 2009 at 11:26 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

" Gay marriage is only immoral in certain religions" So that makes it...

SLC council OKs gay rights policies

To Mark at 10:20, Kalamazoo just passed its anti-discrimination ordinace...

Re: More to Denny G: You also have to get past a great coaching staff that...

the "truth" is that if you are a conservative and do not have the facts on...

If we aren't going to play D, then we might as well be Phoenix. At least they...

2A: Broncos vs. Wildcats

Just hang on the travel issue all you want. If thats the only thing you can...

Letters: Trash or truth?

TO "Dr. Adrenaline | 11:10 a.m." but Obama, Pelosi, and Reid all use the same...

Look, I am a Utah man and I am very proud of what they accomplished over the...

Sloan may toy with starting lineup

DID NOT re-sign Brewer for what he was asking. Can you hear that in the...

Utes remain silent about BCS

Utah will lose to TCU and BYU and will be invited to the Bow Tidley Tech bowl...

Advertisements
Advertisement