In the air — Carbon monoxide crusade: Duo's war against HUD

HUD homes can be deadly, the men say

Published: Saturday, March 7, 2009 11:45 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Babies are dying as you read this, says Tom Rodgers. "Gassed," is how he puts it on a Web site with alarming domain names: GassingAmerica.us, DeadlyFumes.us, HUDsToxicHell.us.

The problem, he says, is that HUD-manufactured homes — the millions of low-cost factory-built homes that fall under federal regulations — typically come equipped with furnace exhaust vents on the roof that are placed too close to the powered air-intake pipe. Under certain conditions — depending on wind direction and snow accumulation on the roof — the exhaust is sucked back in, he argues, and that means that carbon monoxide wafts unseen through the house.

Rodgers, a retired scientist, and his friend Jay Bishop, a retired chemical engineer, are adamant about this. For the past year they have doggedly tried to get the attention of state and local officials, as well as the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, which oversees the homes.

To Rodgers and Bishop, it's simply a matter of common sense. You would never let a child play 3 feet from a car exhaust pipe, they argue, and yet HUD code allows the furnace exhaust vent to be located as close as 3 horizontal feet from the powered air intake. Most municipal codes put that distance at no closer than 10 feet (sometimes 12 feet) horizontally, or 3 feet vertically.

Story continues below

Despite a year of lobbying, their main success so far is an e-mail sent from HUD's office of press relations to the Deseret News, 10 months after the two men first contacted the federal department: "HUD has the matter under review. Based on the results of that review, it may be referred to the Manufactured Housing Consensus Committee for their recommendations."

According to HUD spokesman Lemar Wooley, Rodgers' inquiry is the first the department has received about the possible carbon-monoxide danger in HUD homes, although HUD has allowed the 3-foot vent-intake design for more than 30 years.

It's hard to know what to make of the lack of complaints. Does it mean that there haven't been any problems? Or that the problems have gone undetected and misdiagnosed? Like much in this saga, it's hard to tell what is proof and what is not. It's hard to know whether proof should matter.

Recent comments

I am Thomas L Rodgers, who was contacted by the Conrad family for...

Thomas L Rodgers | March 10, 2009 at 10:31 a.m.

I must point out that none of you Tom Rodgers haters out there showed...

Father of Baby Daniel | March 9, 2009 at 7:25 p.m.

Dear need attention,

You are correct that some news is good and...

Need attention and not news | March 9, 2009 at 5:16 p.m.

Image

Dave and Mary Conrad play with 18-month-old son Daniel inside their HUD-approved modular home in Manti last week.

previousnext

Latest comments

Why not just seal off the area where the body is but leave the rest open?...

Miller predicted Tiger's rough road

I disagree with Observation-ist when he says "It's both illogical and...

Nutty Putty Cave to be sealed today

This is a very sad story, but as a climber I don't think it's right to close...

According to economists, the best way to create permanent jobs would be to...

Letters: Can't play together

The difference 11:22 I don't agree that there are NO_STANDARDS_whatsoever...

Harpring's NBA career is over

Bring him back as an ass't replacing Layden next year then when Sloan & Phil...

Study: Global warming not easing

This is all obviously from the same brilliant minds looking the other way on...

$501 per hour.

I do hope that soon the comments will end, whether you are for or against...

Senators seek cost controls

"Who are we targeting in health care?" Old people. We're rationing the care...

Advertisements