In our opinion: Drop in mine deaths a start

Published: Monday, Jan. 12, 2009 12:04 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

In the aftermath of the Crandall Canyon mine disaster, Richard Stickler, the acting head of the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration, became a familiar face to Utahns.

As the nation's chief mining regulator, it was abundantly clear that Stickler took a deep, personal interest in mining safety. When nine men died in the Crandall Canyon Mine in 2007, he grieved and prayed with the families. Stickler, who has worked in underground mines as a miner and inspector, vowed to find the cause of the cave-ins that killed six miners and three other men who attempted to rescue them. He kept his word.

So it is no surprise that Stickler wasn't satisfied that mining deaths in the United States in 2008 were at their lowest level since regulators began keeping records. Fifty-one miners perished last year — 29 in coal mines and the rest in copper, stone and other kinds of mines. As Stickler told The Associated Press, "That is unacceptable and disheartening."

Story continues below

True. But the number represents a significant decrease in mining-related deaths from 2006, when 73 miners were killed, and 2007, when 67 died, among them the Crandall Canyon miners. MSHA officials said the sharp reduction in fatalities was due to revamped safety laws and stepped-up enforcement. MSHA added 360 mine inspectors and paid $10 million in overtime to complete mandatory safety reviews at all of the nation's coal mines in 2008. This was the first time in the agency's 31-year history that the required inspections were done within a year.

But, as Stickler laments, there is always room for improvement. United Mine Workers of America officials say while mining deaths in 2008 were down overall, the number of coal-mining deaths in 2008 was higher than the record low, 23 deaths in 2005.

Mining is inherently risky. But strong regulations, enforcement and a company's commitment to safety can help curb risks and improve a company's bottom line. Further reduction of mining deaths should be a priority for the Obama administration. The men and women who labor in the nation's mining industry should work under the safest conditions possible. That will require an ongoing commitment to mine inspections and regulations that enhance the safety of the nation's mining industry.

Recent comments

Stickler was a part of the foxes guarding the hen house gang. The...

Displeased | Jan. 12, 2009 at 9:26 p.m.

With the high risk of driving I bet more traveling salesmen die a...

Frank | Jan. 12, 2009 at 1:33 p.m.

The nation needs to combat unchallenged big business anti labor by...

Mike | Jan. 12, 2009 at 11:58 a.m.

Image
Deseret News archives

MSHA chief Richard Stickler speaks to the Deseret News editorial board in 2007.

previousnext

Latest comments

Maya was wronged. The trophy was stolen. The judges had to give him a 30 so...

Go Coug's I'll be there at LES and I expect a great finsh from Max Pitta and Co.

Y. focused on 10-win season

At least he won't be a stupid Junior. Has anyone played worse in the rivalry...

I was hoping they would win, but the were up against a lot of great talent....

I agree completely with your comments about Jay Leno. He goes way to far and...

I, too, think Mr. Gale does a great job with his articles. His...

We should drill more and lower the price globally for oil. Fine build nuclear...

Utahns prove love for Twilight

No I don't own a poster of shirtless Jacob - but there is a huge difference...

Gary, What nonsense! Specify the emails that "prove" deception. You...

if you guys don't think soccer is a sport? then what do you consider a sport?...

Advertisements