Give juries final say

Published: Tuesday, Jan. 6, 2009 12:05 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Spencer Robinson (Readers' Forum, Jan. 4) really has things upside down; his hypothetical defendant could always ask for a non-jury trial. Not only should juries have the final say, but they should have it as to the law as well as to the facts. The Founding Fathers considered juries a cornerstone of justice, a constitutional protection against lawyers, judges and legalized corruption. That juries should be 12 stooges required to adhere to every utterance of black-robed lawyers is a relatively recent phenomenon in the judicial march to power.

There probably has not been a trial by citizen peers in the last 50 years. Legal distortions and technical games extend trials ad nauseam until most won't even show up for selection; juries have almost been destroyed by voir dire and the peremptory challenge.

Who can remember when 12 everyday Americans were last seated on a jury panel?

Paul Sharp

Salt Lake City

Recent comments

I was called to jury selection a number of years ago and I can assure...

@Geez,Paul! | Jan. 6, 2009 at 11:56 p.m.

Where have you been, Paul? Go to the Matheson courthouse and...

Geez, Paul! | Jan. 6, 2009 at 1:32 p.m.

In a letter to Major John Cartwright, in June 1824, Thomas Jefferson...

small jurisdictions | Jan. 6, 2009 at 5:50 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

New charges added in fraud case

As much as Rick may be guilty, as I believe he his, he does have his rights...

Aggies picked to win WAC

There seems to be a lot of WAC and Utah State envy posted.

Or perhaps Obama, like Putin, doesn't think the demise of totalitarianism is...

Rex Lee was one of the finest men I have ever know. The post office renaming...

BYU soccer coverage sparks debate

Re: John- you saw the BYU player elbow the UNM player. What was not shown...

KSL investigation: Affinity fraud

I'd sooner have my choir director get rich by ripping me off rather than a...

Cartman, you probably never donated money to them in the first place. How do...

Tavernari has matured

Since when did losing all those first round NCAA games become a jinx. The MW...

AMEN!!!! I've talked to my supervisors about this for the last 7 or 8 years...

Now there are two people with brain damage,the mother and the child.

Advertisements
Advertisement