Concerns arise over judge's defeat
Governor blames nominee's rejection on partisan politics
The Senate last week, for the first time in recent memory, voted 16-12 against confirming Hilder for a slot on the appellate bench after some legislators inquired into the judge's divorce and criticized Hilder's "demeanor."
Many Utah attorneys and others who work in the courts were puzzled by the questions about divorce and flabbergasted at remarks about Hilder's demeanor since his courtroom behavior is polite and even-tempered to the point of being almost old-fashioned in its courtliness.
Some Utah legislators, however, criticized the 3rd District judge for what they termed showing a hot temper and getting red-faced during closed-door questioning. Those same lawmakers downplayed their concerns over what they've called an anti-gun rights ruling by Hilder.
Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. on Monday blamed "partisan political considerations" for the defeat, noting that the newly elected Senate majority leadership waited until after the vote to finalize committee assignments.
But Huntsman instead said some lawmakers who promised him they'd vote for Hilder ended up voting against the judge including outgoing Senate President John Valentine, R-Orem.
Valentine said he had initially supported Hilder, but he told the governor's office he'd changed his mind after the nominee "was very harsh with me." He dismissed the idea that the vote on Hilder was used to help senators get the committee assignments they wanted.
"That had nothing to do with it," Valentine said. "Normally, we vote yes for the governor's appointments. You get the benefit of the doubt. But when the evidence starts mounting, people get nervous about voting yes."
Huntsman said he isn't going to allow the vote to affect how he views future nominees. Nor, the governor said, does he believe what happened to Hilder will affect the number or quality of applicants for the bench.
Others disagree.
"I do think this will have a chilling effect on future potential nominees," said Paul Cassell, a former federal judge and now a law professor at the University of Utah.
Recent comments
He LIED to the voters about his judges having less than 6 cases under...
Hilder is a fraud | Nov. 29, 2008 at 5:19 a.m.
Most judges in Utah are completely incompetent and corrupt. Everyone...
Personal Injury Attorney | Nov. 28, 2008 at 9:07 p.m.
As I understand the U gun case, Judge Hilder decided that the...
Jim Dexter | Nov. 26, 2008 at 11:39 a.m.
- Former Ute Gross breaks right ankle 10:24 p.m.
- NBA roundup: Mavs halt Pistons 10:20 p.m.
- Pondexter leads No. 14 Huskies 10:17 p.m.
- Lakers booed at home in loss 10:16 p.m.
- Colts take advantage of Pats' gamble 10:13 p.m.
- Serbian Orthodox Patriarch dies 10:13 p.m.
- World datelines 10:12 p.m.
- French, Afghan troops face danger 10:12 p.m.
- U.N. may get plea to intervene 10:11 p.m.
- Photo: Rally in Honduras 10:10 p.m.
- BYU happy to escape with victory
228 - TCU creams U.
222 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
206 - Will state consider gay rights law?
149 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
133 - Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?
131 - RSL heads to MLS title game
124 - Utes remain silent about BCS
120 - Celtics crush Jazz
104 - TCU stays 4th in AP; Y. 19th, U. 23rd
91
Sears is holding a special VIP night Sunday, Nov. 15, in stores and online.
How do you handle kids and contests? Our oldest daughter, 7, is of the...
Bennett is a conservative Bennett is NOT a lifetime politician Bennett...
I agree, time for a change. Lose Sloan or lose the fans,,,,real soon.
im not some BYU posing as a Utah fan, im a huge Utah fan and hate seeing them...
I've followed BYU sports for over 50 years and was very excited by the '84...
CNN is hardly raw news free of analysis and without bias.
Playing lousy is never good. If it were, BYU would have been a monster after...
TCU's footballers aren't any better than BYU's or Utah's, but they are better...
Hey all of you 2A teams and fans. Is San Juan so predictable? Im not sure....
BYU has been up and down under the watch of Bronco. IF I hear them say "its...
Thank you Jerry Sloan for 20 years of coaching the Jazz. But it is time to...
