Time is right for ethics rules

Published: Wednesday, Nov. 19, 2008 12:18 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

We're wondering how many Utahns think it's OK that former state House speaker Greg Curtis gets to take the almost $400,000 left over in his campaign accounts and do with it as he pleases, whether that means giving it to charity or simply pocketing it. How many people think it's OK for other unsuccessful candidates or retiring lawmakers to do the same with much lesser amounts that still add up to tens of thousands of dollars?

We're guessing most people would find such an idea distasteful. They may even wonder how Utah, a state that likes to pride itself on its conservative and values-driven work ethic, could allow such a thing.

Retiring Sen. Dan Eastman told this newspaper he thinks it's OK to let lawmakers do as they please with leftover money because, "You elect honorable people, and they will use it in honorable ways." If that were always the case, people might have no need to worry. But of course, Utah's Legislature is a body of human beings, and they tend to act in similar ways as other human beings — some honorably, some not.

People donate to campaigns for many reasons, but most have something to do with furthering an agenda or gaining influence in the public arena, not with enriching individuals.

For the record, Curtis has in the past said he won't keep any of his leftover money for himself but will instead donate it to charity, other candidates or the Republican Party. Eastman also will donate to charity and politicians and possibly keep some for himself, he said.

Story continues below

They didn't create the current system that allows such freedom with campaign funds. But a majority of lawmakers have consistently stood in the way of changes that would limit personal enrichment. That, we hope, is about to change.

Rep. Dave Clark, R-Santa Clara, is the new House speaker. He has proposed a series of ethics reforms that, if enacted, would go far toward instilling a greater sense of public confidence in state lawmakers. One of these proposals is to limit the things a retiring lawmaker could do with his leftover funds. Charities, candidates or political causes would be OK. Personal pocketbooks would not. He also would ban lawmakers from accepting most gifts, including free meals. And he would institute a one-year waiting period from the time a person leaves office until he or she can become a registered lobbyist.

These are common-sense reforms. They are similar to what Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. has proposed. We hope this push from people in power finally shakes loose the opposition that has kept such reforms from serious consideration in the past.

Money tends to be a legitimate concern in a part-time citizen legislature. The men and women who serve do so often by sacrificing some of the money they otherwise would make at their full-time jobs. We support a healthy increase in the $15,000 or so state lawmakers receive in pay and expenses for their efforts. That might make a reasonable trade-off for the loss of other liberties with donations and gifts.

Recent comments

@Correct if I am wrong? 5:27a

I believe you're wrong. Federal...

Doug Cortney | Nov. 19, 2008 at 8:56 p.m.

Curtis was one paranoid politician. He used some of his...

Government Man. | Nov. 19, 2008 at 6:35 p.m.

Greg Curtis took this money from Special Interest groups that...

Sandy Snooper. | Nov. 19, 2008 at 6:29 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

5A: Bingham rolls to title game

Davis is not Playing a region 4 team, Bingham is in Region 3. Isn't Davis one...

Scam: $59M down drain?

It is so so sad. I hope the middlemen in all of this will serve jail time as...

TCU up 7-0

I guess that means that there is no excuse for the embarrassments of UT vs....

The joy has just begun. First TCU touchdown in just minutes.

Snowstorm hits Utah; 1 dead in crash

Iris was a very good friend to my family. When we heard the news we were in...

The way I found out about Craig, it was while I was searching on YouTube, for...

Letters: Back up claims with proof

Those are examples of CLASSIC liberals, even JEsus and Bible is an example...

Gotta love Ute fans. "only wins matter, not the score". I've only heard...

Gerald, how about you think about how it might be if one day you woke up not...

Advertisements
Advertisement