From Deseret News archives:

San Francisco's universal health plan upheld

Published: Wednesday, Oct. 1, 2008 12:11 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — San Francisco's landmark universal health care program can continue to operate, after an appeals court ruled Tuesday that it does not violate federal law.

The unanimous ruling by a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a lower court decision that the program had placed an undue financial burden on struggling businesses.

The plan, called Healthy San Francisco, is the first plan in the country to offer universal coverage, and requires companies with at least 20 workers to provide health care or give part of each employee's hourly salary to the city as a fee to help offset the program's estimated $200 million cost.

The monthly fee is capped at $180 per worker for businesses with more than 100 employees.

In its ruling, the panel stressed that it was not ruling on the wisdom of the plan, but only the legality of the mandatory employer fees under the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA.

"We are asked only to decide whether ERISA pre-empts the employer spending requirements. We hold that it does not," Judge William A. Fletcher wrote in the court's opinion.

Story continues below
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors approved the program in 2006. A trade association for the city's restaurants sued, arguing that the fee requirement violated a federal law that gives employers a choice in how to provide health coverage.

Kevin Westlye, executive director of the Golden Gate Restaurant Association, said the group planned to appeal.

"If this stands, many counties and states will pass their own employer expenditure rulings, going against why Congress passed ERISA in the first place," Westlye said.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in February that the Healthy San Francisco program could proceed while the appeals court considered its legality.

More than 29,000 people are enrolled, according to the latest city statistics. Previous estimates put the city's uninsured population at about 82,000.

City Attorney Dennis Herrera, whose office argued the case for the city, said the court's ruling proves that local governments can navigate complex federal laws to provide improved health care to residents.

"This is a road map for state and local governments so they can step into the void and fill the vacuum that the federal government has left because of its inability to act in this area," Herrera said.

Labor advocates also hailed the ruling as an important first step in paving the way for health care reform, a key national issue in an election year.

"No one thinks that San Francisco on its own is going to solve the health care problem in the city or the nation," said Ken Peters, chair of the University of California, Berkeley's Center for Labor Research and Education, who worked with city officials on the program. "What San Francisco has shown, however, is that it's a matter of will, it can be done."

Westlye said he agreed with the need for a universal health care plan, but that it could be funded by a quarter-cent sales tax increase instead of employer fees.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

good luck cougs against the falcons! after watching a now 0-10 team almost...

TCU plows past Utes, 55-28

Before you make a comment like that man, why don't you go do some research,...

BYU honors slain soldier

It's sad when a truly Great One is taken. I'm sure he'll be a Great One on...

Collie is amazing. Alex Smith was amazing. I hated him when he was at the...

Glad we got in our Fiesta and Sugar Bowl trophies when we did. TCU will be...

5A: Wolverines showed heart

DAVIS WAS LUCKY #4 WASNT PLAYING.. CUZ THEN HE WOULDVE POUNDED DAVIS LIKE HE...

TCU plows past Utes, 55-28

"By the time you play BYU you will be lucky to be back in the Top 25!" Do...

Okay let's get this straight. If Utah wins a game they were outplayed in...

4A soccer all-state first team

Tell me why Sky View and Mountain Crest got snubbed from the first team and...

RSL advances to MLS Cup

We made it to the final!!! The first major league title for the state of...

Advertisements
Advertisement