From Deseret News archives:

Collider sparking wonder — and fear

Published: Monday, Sept. 15, 2008 12:28 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The world's most powerful particle collider is up and running, but the Large Hadron Collider will idle along at 1/14th of its peak, speed-of-light specs for the next several weeks.

In the meantime, a debate continues amping up. It's the buzz among skeptics in the blogosphere and has been the muse for at least one hip-hop poet. No matter whom you ask, the LHC is already a pretty inspiring piece of equipment.

Opponents have been moved to predictions of doomsday scenarios that regard it as a 17-mile-long catalyst to catastrophe. Being bunkered 300 feet below the border of France and Switzerland safely beyond the layman's view has only fueled the fears that it's a $10 billion money pit with enough power to literally create a black hole.

That's a sentiment that is not shared among physicists, including those in Utah, who regard the LHC as a doorway to a new era of basic science research they've been anticipating for more than 20 years.

Utah made a bid for the Superconducting Super-Collider in the mid-1980s but lost out to Texas, which also ultimately lost, too, when Congress pulled the plug due to a price tag that would rival expenditures for the NASA space program. The new accelerator/collider at CERN (the European Organization for Nuclear Research), was Europe's answer to the SSC.

Story continues below
Switching on the LHC is not a eureka moment for physicists, but having a machine capable of bringing the cosmos into the lab comes pretty close

What might be learned or how the future could be affected by what it reveals really isn't the point right now, and its potential danger is being overstated to say the least, said Utah State University physicist Stan Larson, noting that having the capacity to go the deepest humans have ever been able to probe into the nature and behavior of the basic matter of all life is a marvel in itself.

Many calculations have been done by hundreds of scientists around the world about the possible creation of black holes by the LHC, Larson said. "There have been no significant disagreements in the results of all those calculations — if a micro-black hole is created by the LHC, the expectation is it will escape from the gravitational field of the Earth and travel out into space, he added.

"Nature reaches the energies covered by the LHC every day, right here on Earth," he said. "The Earth is constantly being bombarded by cosmic rays — high energy particles from outer space that reach energies similar to and in excess of the energy of the LHC every second of every day. That being the case, if it is easy and plausible to make black holes, then Nature is already doing it every day right over our heads."

Recent comments

Yesterday my dog died and my keys disappeared. Stupid black holes!...

Fun fun | Sept. 16, 2008 at 1:22 p.m.

i think there would be a dark whole dig 300 ft into the ground but it...

angelina | Sept. 15, 2008 at 11:47 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

And what was the percentage increase by gays in hate crimes against Mormons...

RSL defied doubters to win title

You're right, it seems like 8:12 is wound a little too tight at the moment....

Who has ever tried to "deny religious rights afforded in the Constitution"?...

Expect epic clash on the line

TCU will get into a big money bowl game this season and ewetah has been to...

I am so proud of Donny to keep up with the pro. The body may be not extend...

Tex: This article shows up on Utes sports and the TDS sports so you get off...

Poster at 8:27, the only thing missing from your comment is maybe another...

RSL's Russell left exposed

hopefully they take russell he is one of the laziest defenders i have ever...

Letters: 2 grumpy old men

What about those who do not choose to have health care? How about those who...

If BYU wishes to tone down the rivalry, perhaps they should start with...

Advertisements