From Deseret News archives:

Gay marriage criticized at Education Week address

Published: Saturday, Aug. 23, 2008 12:34 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PROVO — Legalizing same-sex marriage will have significant, long-term societal, fiscal and legal consequences just as smoking and divorce do, even among those who don't personally participate.

That's the assessment from Lynn Wardle, a professor of law at Brigham Young University, who encouraged an audience of attorneys at the school's annual Education Week on Thursday to speak out in opposition to same-sex marriage, rather than being silenced by fear.

"Legalizing same-sex marriage or civil unions endangers not only marriage as an institution but will endanger the civil rights" of those who don't approve of it, Wardle said. "It's about the right to express opposition, and those who do so already suffer harassment and hostility."

As one of very few law professors who speak publicly against it, Wardle said he's been screamed at during the proceedings of large and respected organizations. "I've been called homophobic by a state senator."

"Hate-filled, homophobic, narrow-minded and bigoted — those are the labels you'll get. Those of you who live in California, put on your armor," he said, referring to an upcoming ballot measure that would strike down a recent Supreme Court ruling there legalizing gay marriage.

Story continues below
"Those attacks are purely an effort to silence, harass and drive out of the public square those who oppose them," he said.

"That's the greatest concern I have, the effort to intimidate and silence those who have different views. I've had professors I greatly respect come up to me in dark hallways and tell me they agree with me, but they won't stand up in a meeting and say so. They're afraid of the criticism they'll endure."

Changing the core definition of marriage will lead to clashes between those who have religious views about marriage and those who don't. "Those who want to promote conjugal marriage will be targeted," and many already have been, he said.

Most people who hear much from same-sex marriage proponents but little from the opposition wonder what the harm is, Wardle said. "It's not like a bone sticking out of a limb or blood spurting out of a wound. ... It will be at least a full generation before all the consequences are known. Like smoking, it will take years and decades to see the result."

He likened the consequences to the effect of divorce on children, recalling debates on the subject when he was a law school student. The notion of harm to children "was resoundingly rejected ... everybody said it's tough initially but it will be OK and there will be no lasting effects."

Recent comments

Honestly, there are only a couple of logical things that people need...

Common Sense | Oct. 29, 2008 at 8:50 a.m.

Wardle argues that, like smoking and divorce, gay marriage will have...

Please. | Oct. 19, 2008 at 5:22 a.m.

Get a book, read some history.

to person @10;06pm 9/12 | Sept. 27, 2008 at 12:04 p.m.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

TCU creams U.

Ribbit Ribbit Ribbit Ribbit

We protected democracy in Utah

This commission is populated by political insiders whose voting record shows...

Having RSL go far in MLS is like the McGuire/Sosa home-run derby after the...

TCU creams U.

Has anyone checked on Sorenson and Doug Robinson to see how they are holding up?

Hall ties Detmer's record for wins

Max deserves the record but it's too bad that Ty's last game as a Cougar...

Manning to Collie show coming to a theater near you!

Same old story for Jazz

If the Jazz had won the 6 games they have lost, they'd be undefeated. 10-0....

'Restoring' is like saying 'tax hike'

Mr. Evensen is correct when he says the leigislature will be sending a...

5A: Wolverines showed heart

Thank you Wolverines for your fine sportsmanship you displayed when you met...

TCU creams U.

Lulz @ Utes

Advertisements
Advertisement