From Deseret News archives:

Book confronts LDS tragedy

Published: Saturday, July 19, 2008 12:08 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
As they meticulously pieced together what some are calling the most complete history ever written of the Mountain Meadows Massacre, much of the agony was in the irony for three Latter-day Saint authors.

"What did the terrible atrocity say about the killers?" who were led by local LDS Church leaders in southern Utah. "What did it say about their church and its leaders? Did early Mormonism possess a violent strain so deep and volcanic that it erupted without warning?"

The questions in the book's preface played out not only in the authors' daily research, but it haunted their daydreams and served up nightmares, they said.

As active members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and all current or former church employees, Ron Walker, Richard Turley and Glen Leonard found themselves immersed in the twisted horror of seemingly godly men trying to justify the cold-blooded murder of 120 men, women and children during nearly a decade of research and writing.

Yet their new book, "Massacre at Mountain Meadows," is dedicated to those most often overlooked in most of the scholarly and secular accounts of the tragedy: "To the victims."

Story continues below
Scheduled for release next month by Oxford University Press, the long-awaited historical account was purposely constructed as a narrative for general readers, bolstered with copious footnotes and indexes, rather than as a scholarly point-counterpoint treatise to address the work of previous historians.

Unlike many previous LDS accounts of the tragedy, it portrays the wagon train emigrants passing through southern Utah in September 1857 as ordinary people with bright futures and some flaws rather than as scoundrels who somehow deserved to die.

Instead of defending the perpetrators — as some both inside and outside the LDS Church believed the book would do — it names the local LDS leaders and their dark deeds in detail, culling from affidavits given to a 19th century church historian by those who participated in the slaughter or learned of it firsthand. The information, which has never before been available to researchers, came from archives owned by the LDS Church, including those of the faith's First Presidency.

What the book doesn't do is implicate then-LDS Church President Brigham Young in directing or ordering the killings. It does describe how his wartime preaching and that of other top LDS leaders contributed to the atmosphere of unquestioned authority, conformity, fear and suspicion that ended with terrible, "unexpected consequences."

Digging for truth

Recent comments

Hi everyone. There is still a difference between something and...

Anonymous | July 5, 2009 at 2:22 p.m.

How are you. Make a decision, even if it's wrong.
I am from Belgium...

Anonymous | July 3, 2009 at 8:01 a.m.

Estamos atravesando el tiempo de nuestra existencia terrenal. Solo...

jennyz | Sept. 18, 2008 at 5:13 p.m.

Image

Richard Turley, left, and Ron Walker, co-authors of "Massacre at Mountain Meadows," at the Church Office Building in Salt Lake City in June.

previousnext

Latest comments

Boys basketball rankings

Hey I just noticed that the Des News has the girls' basketball all-state...

Letters: Trump card for believers

You state: "The Government is NOT here to insure that YOU have equal rights."...

Brad Rock: Rock on ...

Is Kyle Whittingham really shopping himself around to other programs? That...

TV wouldn't "dominate" 5A, nor would they be an "average 5A" team. I would...

Is it ethical to hold an opinion on an initiative you haven't read?

If you go to google streetview and lookm at the house imediately west of the...

Ex-legislators call for ethics reform

The "ethics" problem in Utah is not a problem. Period. We have one of the...

"Go Support your Brothers | 5:10 p.m. Nov. 24, 2009 Hey Bingham Football...

I'm glad to see that America is still America, and the 1st Amendment stands....

Utah, BYU are top choices for bowls

The winner of the utah/byu game is the real loser if they get the ice-bowl in...

Advertisements