From Deseret News archives:

He said, she said: Critics take a Mars-vs.-Venus look at 'Dark Knight,' 'Mamma Mia'

Published: Thursday, July 17, 2008 4:33 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Men and women may see eye to eye on a lot of things. But movies usually aren't one of them.

In theory, there are films that appeal to either male sensibilities or female ones, which may explain why something like the recent "Sex and the City" film can make $140 million with a predominantly female audience.

And it also shows why a decidedly male-skewing thriller like "Wanted" can bust past the $100-million mark as well.

So, in the interest of science — well, in the interest of something interesting — Deseret News film critic Jeff Vice and theater critic Erica Hansen decided an experiment was in order.

The idea was the two would watch the same two movies — one of them a supposed "chick flick," the other a big "manly movie" — and then see what, if anything, they agreed upon. Here are the results:

'The Dark Knight'

THE MOVIE: "The Dark Knight" (rated PG-13). A sequel to 2005's "Batman Begins," starring Christian Bale as the Caped Crusader and Heath Ledger as his nemesis, the Joker.

Story continues below
HE LIKED: It's dark. Really dark. In fact, it almost makes "Batman Begins" look like a Saturday morning cartoon. But that darkness is appropriate for this material, and Heath Ledger is amazing as the Joker. His performance really deserves all the early Oscar talk.

SHE LIKED: Ummm ... well ... I enjoyed Christian Bale (my friend was right, ladies love Bruce Wayne). I liked Aaron Eckhart, and Heath Ledger was certainly creepy enough. Plus Morgan Freeman and Michael Caine are always great.

HE DIDN'T LIKE: It's dark. Really dark. In fact, as disturbing as parts are, I wonder if the film should have gotten an R rating instead of PG-13. This is definitely not a kids film.

SHE DIDN'T LIKE: Most of the movie. I'm sorry, but what happened? These movies used to be so much fun — some great action sequences, definitive good guys and bad guys and a funny line or two. This was so dreary. It felt horribly long, and it was horribly loud! By explosion No. 7,567 I was ready to bawl. That being said, if you are a Batman fan, you'll probably love the movie; the crowd sure did.

Recent comments

Also, I'm not sure what Erica was thinking when she said there was no...

LG | July 19, 2008 at 2:14 p.m.

Breathless: The reason you probably won't see people singing along to...

LG | July 19, 2008 at 2:09 p.m.

It was great -- the whole theater I was in cheered and sang along at...

loved Mama Mia | July 19, 2008 at 10:57 a.m.

Image
Warner Bros.

Heath Ledger as the Joker

previousnext

Latest comments

Obama: More troops with deadline

Yepper's, you betcha, (as Sarah Palin would say), the same DNA is running in...

Wouldn't you think the victim would have been killed INSIDE the home if he...

Max Hall: a fixture in rivalry lore

The bottom line is no matter how much you don't like the other team you don't...

Letters: Hatred is uncalled for

I HATE THE U | 12:02 p.m. You all have similar stories because they are...

This is a really cool story, thanks for writing it 7 congrats to the family.

MWC '09 season in review

No matter what the cougs do - they will be linked to the Vegas bowl - enjoy...

JT is an excellent player and I hate when people bag on him. Yes, he has poor...

6 sons soar as Eagle Scouts

What does scouting actually have to do with being awesome?... Answer:...

Letters: Left-wing AP

'And your last sad attempt, the James Early Ray "quote" is simply a lie.' -...

"One thing you can't hide, is when you're crippled inside." John Lennon.

Advertisements