From Deseret News archives:

California court denies Shurtleff request to delay same-sex marriages

Published: Wednesday, June 4, 2008 4:26 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The California Supreme Court has denied a request by Utah and nine other states to delay its ruling allowing same-sex marriages until after the November election.

Paul Murphy, spokesman for the Utah Attorney General's Office, said the request for the stay was aimed at preventing the potential for unnecessary litigation.

"We're disappointed and we will prepare to defend the state against any (marriage) recognition lawsuits, and do the best we can to make sure taxpayers don't bare the brunt of this litigation," Murphy said.

Wednesday's decision means that same-sex couples will be able to marry in California on June 17.

The Gay Rights advocacy group Equality Utah issued a statement praising the court's decision, saying, "we can now celebrate with Californians who can now enter into civil marriage without delay."

However, in November, California voters will decide whether to overrule the Supreme Court by amending the state constitution to ban gay marriage.

"People are going to get married in June," Murphy said. "In November voters will decide whether that will continue. During that time, marriages will be taking place."

Story continues below
Attorney General Mark Shurtleff had petitioned the court last week for the stay on behalf of himself and nine other attorney generals, saying the states could face "premature, unnecessary, unnecessarily difficult" lawsuits. California conservative religious and political groups had also requested delays and rehearings.

The 4-3 decision to deny those requests came with the same four justices in the majority who comprised the earlier majority opinion that it was discriminatory to deny marriage rights to same-sex couples. The majority didn't give reasons for denying the stay in its one-page order.

Unlike Massachusetts, the first state in the nation to allow same-sex marriage, California has no residency requirements for its marriage licenses.

Utah's constitution prohibits recognition of same-sex marriage and other domestic unions. However, the state could face a federal challenge on whether the U.S. Constitution requires recognition of the California marriages.

That question has been "hotly debated" by legal scholars for over a decade, said Monte Stewart, president of the Marriage Law Foundation, which supports traditional marriage.

"It is absolutely extraordinary that in about five months the marriage definition in California may well return to the union of a man and a woman," Stewart said. "You're going to have a very complicated issue at that point."

Regardless of whether or not there is litigation, Equality Utah's statement pointed to the group's ongoing support for advocates and political candidates who will work for policy change here.

"What's more important is how we move forward in an effort to achieve a fair and just Utah," the statement said. "Until and unless the law of our great land protects every citizen, it protects no one."


E-mail: dbulkeley@desnews.com

Recent comments

Shurtz, you'd do well to focus on the Kidnapping Trauma that goes on...

Alice in Kidnapper Land | June 16, 2008 at 3:17 p.m.

That wonder why some of us read the Deseret News online if we...

There have been people | June 8, 2008 at 3:43 p.m.

If rights were put to a vote, would we ever have freed the slaves or...

John L. | June 7, 2008 at 6:48 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Jared Quayle is a stud. He plays like a beast every time he touches the...

No Phx is not a majority LDS city Mesa is. As far as Tom's comment about...

BYU would like friendlier rivalry

Lest my Utah friends think I was just going to bang on my own, I think UteFan...

You can read the official declaration online via a photo of the original....

"McFeatters states that what Palin is doing, and doing brilliantly, is being...

BYU would like friendlier rivalry

don't mean to pick on you but fans from both sides make it easy to despise...

Boys basketball rankings

Nick Paulos is a great shooter, and Connor Brady's decent. But Provo and Kyle...

Explain this to me. He claims a utah fan ran on the field and threw a CUP of...

The International Center for Religion and Diplomacy mentioned in this article...

BYU doesn't have to make the U sound anti-Mormon, it's a fact; there is a...

Advertisements