From Deseret News archives:

California gay marriage ban overturned, but ruling not likely to impact Utah's ban

Published: Thursday, May 15, 2008 6:50 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Gay couples in California may soon be headed to the altar after that state's Supreme Court knocked down a state law banning same-sex marriage.

However, those who follow the national marriage debate say the ruling in the nation's largest state probably won't impact Utah, at least not immediately.

"The short answer is those marriages would not be recognized in Utah," said Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff.

Utah voters, in 2004, approved a constitutional amendment that bans same-sex marriage and other domestic unions.

It was the possibility of a legal challenge in state court that made traditional marriage advocates cite a need for a state constitutional amendment. That amendment was in addition to state law that also bans same-sex unions.

Monte Stewart, president of the Orem-based Marriage Law Foundation, said a legal challenge is more likely to come from a gay couple wed in California than Massachusetts, the nation's first state allowing same-sex marriages. That's because California doesn't have a prohibition against couples from other states wedding there if that marriage is illegal in their state of origin.

Story continues below
"There will now be a flood of recognition cases all across the country," he said. "We would not be surprised to see Utah getting a recognition case or two."

But Stewart isn't worried, because he says the law is clear: "a state does not need to recognize a marriage by a same-sex couple in another state."

Shurtleff says any challenge to Utah's marriage policy will have to come in federal court, and those challenges have already been brought up in other states, as couples wed in Massachusetts have sought recognition of their relationships elsewhere.

"It's well on its way in other jurisdictions," Shurtleff said. "You're now getting these different decisions in different states. That's when the (U.S.) Supreme Court needs to step up and say, 'we've got to decide this.'"

The cases are based on the same constitutional "full faith and credit" provision that requires states to recognize each other's driver licenses.

State Sen. Scott McCoy, D-Salt Lake, says he'd like to see marriage equality but doesn't see it coming through a court challenge. McCoy directed the campaign against Amendment 3 in 2004.

"That has never been used in the 200 years-plus that we've had our constitution to force one state to recognize a marriage from another state," he said. "Utah has clearly stated, and I think wrongly stated, that marriage is between a man and woman and won't recognize a marriage from another state."

Recent comments

Gay life, is a personal and sexual prefference that has grown in...

heavenfaith | Oct. 27, 2008 at 10:02 a.m.

Marriage was a derivative of a biblical need to keep FAMILIES...

Enough! | May 30, 2008 at 9:00 a.m.

The Gay People I know do not regret their decision to come out and be...

Curt | May 20, 2008 at 9:46 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Beck is extremely smart, he is selling books and is very popular on TV. All...

@Mick, the Federal Govt is run by corporations through contributions and...

RSL will play for MLS Cup tonight

Lets bond together and hope for a REAL celebration SUnday night, can hardly...

I was on the playground too and some teachers came out and called us all to...

BYU records with win

B.Y.U. has been a consistent a top 25 ranked winner under Max Hall. Hall has...

4A: Timpview wins 4th in 4 years

Did Timp win four in a row or 4 in 4 years?

Glenn Beck to enter politics?

You have a lot of growing up to do, It seems like you have not cxperienced...

The proposed ethics law puts roughly the same burden on a legislator that a...

BYU records with win

Hall ACTUALLY broke the all timme wins record vs WYO last week. I guess...

Sounds to me like Kraig Powell may be a candidate for resignation. So long,...

Advertisements