In this Jan. 22, 2012 photo, a protester holds a poster of a mainland Chinese scholar and carries a dog during a protest in front of a Beijing's liaison office in Hong Kong. The protesters were upset about an online video of a mainland Chinese scholar who called Hong Kongers dogs, which was itself a response to another video of Hong Kongers quarreling with mainland tourists on a train over their manners. The incidents highlight simmering tension over differing views of Hong Kong's identity.
Vincent Yu, Associated Press
HONG KONG — The argument began over the seemingly minor offense of eating on the subway, which is banned in Hong Kong. A local commuter was outraged that a girl in a tour group from mainland China was spilling noodles onto the floor.
In a video clip that has gone viral, the commuter hits an emergency stop button to alert subway staff.
"I told them they can't eat on the subway," the man tells the subway worker who answers the call. "But then they yelled at me. Hey! This is Hong Kong!" The commuter demands an apology from the girl's mother. She refuses and the argument explodes, with both sides screaming at each other.
The quarrel, between two groups speaking mutually unintelligible dialects of Chinese, isn't just about manners. It also illustrates how — 15 years after this former British colony was handed back to China — Hong Kongers feel less Chinese and more an island unto themselves than ever as they face a growing influx of visitors from the mainland.
And that's a headache for the political masters in Beijing, who are concerned about the threat of disloyalty in the semiautonomous territory and are lashing out against the notion of a separate Hong Kong identity.
Other events also have highlighted the split between Hong Kongers and mainland visitors, who are frequently derided as "locusts" for their voracious buying of everything from apartments to luxury goods to baby formula.
A regular poll found the sense of Hong Kong identity surging. A flood of pregnant mainland women crossing into the city solely to give birth has strained tensions. Even the U.S. consul general has been dragged into the debate after praising Hong Kong for sticking to the "one country, two systems" principle. A well-known Beijing scholar turned up the heat by calling Hong Kongers "dogs" and "bastards."
Hong Kong, which returned to Chinese control in 1997 after more than 150 years as a British colony, is still a global financial center. It's also a special administrative region with Western-style rights and freedoms not seen in mainland China, most notably freedom of speech and the rule of law.
Local councillors and half the legislature are elected by voters while a pro-Beijing committee chooses Hong Kong's leader, though direct elections have been promised as early as 2017.
Beijing's fear is that if Hong Kong continues to have an excessively vibrant culture of its own, it could prompt residents to press for a faster pace of democratization that could lead to a non-pro-Beijing figure elected as the city's leader.
- Nearly half of returning veterans seek...
- Impact of dam flooding to be tested
- Mitt Romney promises world's strongest...
- Studies try to find why poorer people are...
- 21,000 acres ablaze in Michigan
- Olympic hurdler Lolo Jones says she's a...
- Where did Memorial Day originate?
- Does Romney's faith concern a quarter of...
- News analysis: From confidence to...
56 - Does Romney's faith concern a quarter...
47 - Search for Mitt Romney running mate in...
35 - Olympic hurdler Lolo Jones says she's a...
31 - Can U.S. schools adopt education...
26 - Maine churches fighting gay marriage
26 - Studies try to find why poorer people...
26 - Sarah Palin catches flak over her Orrin...
24






DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
— About comments