PHOENIX — An Arizona lawmaker is pushing to create a high school course about the Bible and its role in Western culture with a bill that threatens to drop the state into a constitutional dilemma over the separation of church and state.
At least five other states — all in the Bible Belt — have passed similar legislation and the bill's sponsor says students would benefit from the course because biblical references are everywhere.
Critics say the proposal is unnecessary and divisive and could be unconstitutional because it "sets aside Christianity as a preferred religion."
Republican Rep. Terri Proud of Tucson sponsored the measure, which asks the state Board of Education to design a course called "The Bible and its Influence on Western Culture." The course would be an elective at high schools that choose to offer it.
Public schools across the country have generally avoided Bible courses, but hundreds offer such classes as electives.
The bill stipulates that the course maintain "religious neutrality," and requires the state Attorney General to review the curriculum to ensure it doesn't conflict with the U.S. Constitution.
Proud, who is on the House Education Committee, said she wants students to learn about the Bible's influence on art and literature, noting that there are biblical references in everything from Michelangelo's paintings and Shakespeare's plays to modern movies and television.
"This is such an essential foundation for our kids' knowledge," she said. "We are so engulfed in it."
If students aren't taught those references, Proud said, they face a learning gap from high school to college.
Proud said teachers in her district told her they have a fear of mentioning Christianity or the Bible in the classroom, and she hopes the law will give them some guidance.
"There's nothing wrong with bringing religion into a classroom," she said. "The issue is we can't bring devotion."
In 1963, the U.S. Supreme Court banned ceremonial Bible readings in schools but said "the Bible is worthy of study for its literary and historic qualities" so long as material is "presented objectively as part of a secular program of education."
Georgia in 2006 passed a law supporting voluntary Bible courses that is similar to the Arizona proposal. Texas, Tennessee, South Carolina and Oklahoma have also passed similar laws.
Hundreds of public schools in other states offer elective Bible classes to students even though their state has not passed a law addressing the issue.
Arizona doesn't need to adopt such a law because there's nothing stopping districts from offering it now, said state Sen. Rich Crandall, a Republican who chairs the Senate Education Committee.
However, Crandall said he doesn't have a problem with the bill, and said Proud is looking to reassure school districts.
"She didn't have any ulterior motives," he said.
As long as the course is objective, it's constitutional, said David Cortman, a lawyer with Phoenix-based Alliance Defense Fund, a Christian legal group that supports the Bible classes.
"I believe it's an extremely important type of course to provide just because our culture is so saturated with biblical reference and biblical allusions," Cortman said.
Critics say the course could face legal challenges by bringing religious instruction into public schools.
"It tends to set aside Christianity as a preferred religion. We think that's unconstitutional," said Doug Kilgore with the Arizona Education Association. "We don't believe in passing legislation that's going to be struck down."
- A New York Times article said Michael Brown...
- Running again? Mitt Romney tells Hugh Hewitt...
- Why the poverty cycle is harder to break than...
- 3 ways insurers can still avoid covering the...
- Bound bodies of 2 found in Philly river; 3rd...
- University of Phoenix founder dies, leaving...
- Is James Foley a martyr? A brutal death...
- 10 things to know about corporate inversions
- A New York Times article said Michael... 39
- For the first time in American history,... 30
- Running again? Mitt Romney tells Hugh... 24
- Doug Robinson: When did Missouri turn... 22
- 10 things to know about corporate... 18
- Obama back at White House after summer... 17
- Why the poverty cycle is harder to... 14
- Mourners gather in St. Louis for Brown... 13