Tebow vilified for perfection in the age of anti-heroes

So what is it about Tim Tebow?

By now, even if you don't follow sports, you've probably heard of the Denver Broncos' God-fearing, straight-arrow quarterback.

Which side are you taking — like or dislike?

Not many are in the middle. Tebow is a polarizing figure, and that's the mystery of it all.

What's not to like about Tim Tebow? He's deeply religious, sincere, grateful, clean-cut, unfailingly polite, considerate, kind and devoted to charities, missionary work, and mom and dad. He is seemingly incapable of cynicism, guile and profanity and sports an earnestness we haven't seen since the days of "Leave it to Beaver." If you had a daughter, this is the guy you'd beg her to marry.

If all this weren't enough, Tebow, the most unorthodox quarterback in the NFL since players started wearing helmets (his throwing motion is enough to make purists look away), has turned the 1-4 Broncos into 8-5 division leaders and the talk of professional sports. Half of the wins were Tebow-powered comebacks in the fourth quarter.

And yet he suffers from the same fate as Mitt Romney — so likeable he's unlikeable for some; so perfect, he's too perfect; so good that it must not be real.

At least a couple of opposing players have imitated the prayer position that Tebow strikes on the field, which looks like Rodin's "The Thinker." He has been ripped on Internet message boards for his piousness and supposed self-righteousness and for "wanting to force his views on everyone." He is vilified for beginning his interviews by thanking the Lord and for his public prayers — "Tebowing," it's called — and for wearing his religion on his sleeve, not to mention his face (he once included Biblical passages on his eye black).

It's such a strange phenomenon that columnists and media types are puzzling over it around the country. "Why does Tim Tebow irritate so many people?" asked Daniel Foster in the National Review.

It's not the first time we've seen this phenomenon, although not on this scale. Kurt Warner, another overtly Christian quarterback, similarly turned off fans for the same reasons; even his wife got dragged into the ugliness, largely because TV cameras couldn't resist showing her in the stands. Retired basketball star David Robinson, another devoutly religious man, endured some of this, as well. Shaquille O'Neal wrote in his book that he wanted to dominate Robinson "because I got tired of the goody-two-shoes image he was throwing out there."