Mississippi State's Dan Mullen said two months ago that whoever wins the SEC West is "the best in the country."
If only it were that simple.
While the coach looks like a prophet with LSU, Alabama and Arkansas holding down the top three spots in the national rankings and BCS standings, their 1-2-3 status sets up some potentially wacky scenarios.
The prospects go beyond a much-talked about LSU-Alabama rematch. The eventual national champion could come out of the Southeastern Conference and not have won the league title or its division crown. It's not out of the question that both BCS game participants were just wannabes in the SEC West as the league seeks its sixth-straight national title and third in a row for that division.
"I think if LSU and Alabama win this week, we're probably at a 90 percent chance that they're playing each other for a national championship," said Brad Edwards, a BCS and college football analyst for ESPN. "That 10 percent is if LSU loses to Georgia in such a way that it would discourage voters from keeping them in the top 2."
But if Arkansas beats LSU and Alabama wins — it sets up a three-way tie in the SEC West.
The tiebreaker will come down to head-to-head competition between the two teams ranked highest in the BCS standings. LSU won at Alabama 9-6 in overtime three weeks ago; the Razorbacks fell 38-14 in Tuscaloosa in September.
"In order for Arkansas to win the tiebreaker, I feel like they're going to have to do something so impressive that they end up getting a lot of first-place votes," Edwards said. "A lot of people have to move them over Alabama and into the No. 1 spot.
"What they essentially need is for Alabama to beat Auburn and go backward in the rankings, which isn't likely to happen."
But if Arkansas wins this week and loses the division tiebreaker, Edwards said the Razorbacks still wouldn't necessarily out of the national title picture.
It's so confusing, Tennessee defensive tackle Malik Jackson came up with his own ratings system after playing all three teams.
"I mean, they're all 1-1-1," Jackson said. "You really can't make out a difference, especially between LSU and Bama."
This situation is unheard of even in the SEC, which was the first league to split into divisions in 1992.
It's just the third time three teams from the same division been ranked in the top 5, according to STATS LLC. The Big 12 South did it on two consecutive weeks in November 2008 with No. 2 Texas Tech, No. 4 Texas and No. 5 Oklahoma.
It's the first time since the final regular season poll in 1971 that one league has had teams 1 through 3: The old Big Eight's Nebraska, Oklahoma and Colorado.
"You don't expect it to be 1-2-3, but you expect it to be the best division in the country," Auburn tight end Philip Lutzkenkirchen said. "We're looking forward to trying to change that top 3 a little bit."
One benefit of three division rivals topping the field is that there are more head-to-head comparisons. Tennessee and Mississippi State have both played all three and Auburn is about to join that group.
The Bulldogs lost 19-6 (LSU), 24-7 (Alabama) and 44-17 (Arkansas).
"When you look at those three teams they can keep playing each other and you'd probably have different results every time because of the differences in the teams," Mullen said. "Each one of them has a strong point that is stronger than the other team. It depends on whose strengths get highlighted during the game."
The Volunteers fell to LSU (38-7) and Alabama (37-6) by nearly identical scores and lost to Arkansas 49-7. Coach Derek Dooley says "it's not surprising" those teams comprise the top 3.
- Dick Harmon: How a simple decision in the...
- Hamson and Gray step up big to get BYU past...
- BYU defensive back transferring to Utah State
- BYU football: Cougars in talks with Wagner...
- Ranking the biggest bowl games in University...
- Utah Jazz pick up rare road win against Miami...
- Jazz center Rudy Gobert gets pushy with...
- BYU focusing on bowl game while players'...
- 4-star offensive line commit Kieffer... 68
- BYU has something to prove, looking to... 60
- BYU football: Cougars in talks with... 51
- BYU defensive back transferring to Utah... 50
- BYU sells close to 2,000 tickets for... 37
- Dick Harmon: BYU guard Tyler Haws the... 31
- Dick Harmon: How a simple decision in... 30
- Ute football team has boots on the... 28