Doug Robinson: BYU sold out other sports for football's independence

Published: Tuesday, April 12 2011 11:00 p.m. MDT

"It's all about the money, money, money.

It's about the ba-bling, ba-bling, ba-bling,

And the cha-ching, cha-ching, cha-ching."

— Jesse J

SALT LAKE CITY— Now that basketball and the Season of Jimmer have ended, the countdown has begun: BYU will soon step into the void.

Let's see if we've got this straight. Beginning in the fall, the football team will compete as an independent, without conference affiliation, a la Notre Dame. The school's other sports, except the men's and women's track teams, will compete in the West Coast Conference.

During the winter indoor season, the track team will compete in the Mountain Pacific Sports Federation — whatever that is — but during the spring outdoor season it will compete as an independent.

Not that they were an afterthought, but it took five months after BYU's announcement about the fate of its other teams just to figure out what to do with the track teams. The WCC doesn't have track competition.

So there it is: one school with three different athletic designations, and none that make any sense.

Didn't BYU's "other sports" (non-football) deserve better? The Cougars farmed out most of their teams to the California minor leagues for one reason: to accommodate the football team, which was able to sign a fat contract with ESPN as an independent.

It's all about the money, money, money.

Almost no sport wins in this arrangement, not even football, it could be argued.

Basketball doesn't win in this deal. Instead of playing traditional, natural regional rivals such as Wyoming, Colorado State, Air Force and New Mexico, it's going to play Loyola Marmount, Pepperdine, Saint Mary's, Gonzaga, San Diego (University, not State), and Santa Clara. Wake us when it's over. It's a step backward. They were hoping to do better than the WAC and the MWC — and they wind up in the WCC?

Instead of playing in The Pit, they're going to play in the pits. The basketball arenas are tiny — Pepperdine 3,100, Saint Mary's 3,800, Loyola Marymount 4,100.The biggest is Gonzaga's, at 6,000. Even if filled to capacity, you could combine the crowds from Santa Clara, Saint Mary's, Pepperdine, San Diego and Loyola Marymount and fit them in BYU's Marriott Center — capacity: 22,700 — and still have room for half of San Francisco's fans.

Instead of playing teams that are mediocre but at least have the sound of respectability and the appeal of traditional rivals — Wyoming, New Mexico, Colorado State, etc. — the Cougars are going to play the Loyolas and Pepperdines and San Diegos in what amounts to a can't-win proposition. Sure, many of these schools put good teams on the floor, but they don't have name value or national reputation. They also hold little interest for BYU fans.

The Cougars deserve better in basketball. They came within overtime of advancing to the Elite Eight this season. They produced the Player of the Year. In the last five years, they have won four conference championships and made five NCAA appearances while averaging 27 wins. In 2005, Street and Smith's placed BYU 36th on its list of top 100 greatest college basketball programs of all time. They have collected 30 conference titles and 26 NCAA appearances.

BYU's minor sports don't win in this deal for many of the reasons stated above. Although some of the sports actually might offer tougher competition — swimming, golf, volleyball — the track team got hosed.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere