Monte Poole: The NCAA Tournament that might have been

By Monte Poole

The Oakland Tribune

Published: Friday, March 18 2011 1:03 p.m. MDT

There will be blowouts and buzzer-beaters, upsets and overtimes. There will be shouts of joy and screams of agony, followed by tears and more tears. And you just know there will be expressions of faith.

The First Four behind us, the NCAA tournament has begun its journey to the Final Four, promising hoops at its pulsating best.

No matter how superb the tournament is — and it will be fantastic — it won't come close to being the tournament it might have been.

For as much as I love March Madness in the 21st century, and I have plenty of company here, this is where I hate the influence of the NBA.

I understand the intent of the NBA rule that insists players be at least 19 years old and one year beyond high school graduation before becoming eligible for the draft. It's designed to give young men another year of physical and mental maturity — while "developing" in college.

But the result is our most gifted players using college as a layover to the NBA. This hurts the college game and punishes its signature tournament. Watching the NCAAs reminds us what we're missing.

We're missing Blake Griffin, who would be a senior at Oklahoma, which isn't in the tournament but would have been.

We're missing Kevin Love, who would be a senior at UCLA, which slipped into the tournament but likely would have been a top-four seed.

We're missing Derrick Rose, who would be a senior at Memphis, which is in the tournament but would have been a serious contender — especially if Rose were joined by Tyreke Evans, who would be a junior in the same backcourt.

We're missing John Wall and DeMarcus Cousins, who would be sophomores at Kentucky — and Jonny Flynn and Wesley Johnson, who would be seniors at Syracuse.

How's this for an all-tournament team without any of the aforementioned: center Greg Monroe, who would be a junior at Georgetown; power forward Derrick Favors, who would be a sophomore at Georgia Tech; small forward DeMar DeRozan, who would be a junior at USC; big guard Evan Turner, who would be a senior at Ohio State; and point guard Jerryd Bayless, who would be a senior at Arizona?

There's no room for O.J. Mayo, who would be a senior at USC, or Michael Beasley, who would be a senior at Kansas State.

That's 15 superior talents who could have been participating in March Madness but happen to be earning paychecks in the NBA. Who can blame them? Maybe they needed the money. It's almost certain they neither needed nor wanted college.

They shouldn't have to go. Most of the best players in today's NBA entered the league immediately after high school or after a brief pit stop in college. Kobe Bryant didn't go to college. Neither did LeBron James nor Kevin Garnett nor Dwight Howard.

Rose bided time for a year, following in the footsteps of Kevin Durant (one year at Texas) — though both likely would have bypassed college altogether if not for the age restriction.

Which means none would have experienced the NCAA tournament. And that would be OK, perhaps even preferred. Leave the tournament to those who want to be in college.

Major League Baseball has no age restriction, opting to allow players to turn pro out of high school or after three years of college. That's fair to the schools, the franchises and the individuals. And the process takes nothing away from the College World Series.

Why can't the NBA do the same?

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS