Brian David Mitchell changes carols to avoid the words 'Christ' and 'God'

Published: Thursday, Dec. 2 2010 3:22 p.m. MST

Brian David Mitchell is escorted out of court at the beginning of today's hearing as Elizabeth Smart and her family look on.

Scott Snow

SALT LAKE CITY — Brian David Mitchell professes to be a prophet, called from on high as "the one mighty and strong" to be the Lord's servant in the last days.

But amid the Christmas carols and church hymns he sings daily during his trial, you won't often hear Mitchell singing the words "Christ" or "God."

Mitchell's steady, but weak voice permeates the courtroom morning after morning as he stands trial for the 2002 kidnapping of Elizabeth Smart. The songs, which changed to Christmas carols in mid-November, have become a Mitchell trademark coupled with his long hair and beard. He is routinely removed from the courtroom after he is advised he will have to leave if he persists in singing.

He has been dismissed every day of his trial and during nearly every earlier court hearing.

On Wednesday, Mitchell started in on Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's "I Heard The Bells on Christmas Day," but immediately omitted the word "Christmas," substituting with what sounded like "summer." Later, he skipped over "Christendom" and when he came to the line "God is not dead, nor doth he sleep," Mitchell instead sang: "Hell is not dead, nor doth it sleep."

When Mitchell followed with the song "What Child Is This?" he left out "Christ" during the refrain, "This, this is Christ the King."

He doesn't pause where the word should be, he just fills the space with indecipherable alternatives.

Smart testified earlier during the trial that Mitchell believed he was "the Lord's servant in the last days" and that the Lord had guided him in the kidnapping of Smart. Mitchell consistently identified himself as a traveling preacher. Smart and Mitchell's estranged wife and codefendant, Wanda Barzee, both testified that Mitchell said he spent his days ministering, but that often translated to panhandling.

While he avoids the word "Christ," Mitchell doesn't shy away from "Lord." In a rendition of "Joy to the World" in court on Thursday, Mitchell sang "The Lord is come" more than once. He then started in on "O Come All Ye Faithful" and in the refrain that closes every verse, he replaced "Christ," but finished with "the Lord." There are other references to Jesus Christ he doesn't avoid at all.

"King of Israel."

"Son of the Father."

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS