• Salt Lake City: Scattered Clouds 63°
partlycloudy
Deseret News
Home
  • Login/Register
    • Mobile
    • Mobile Site
    • Text Version
    • Mobile Apps
Powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
  • News
  • Sports
  • Moneywise
  • Opinion
  • Faith
  • Family
  • Obituaries
    • Classifieds
    • Cars
    • Jobs
    • Deals
powered by ksl.com
  • Jazz
  • BYU
  • Utes
  • USU
  • RSL
  • Bees
  • High School
  • Rock
  • Harmon
  • More Sports
    • Watch It
    • Scores and Stats
    • On TV
    • NFL
    • MLB
    • WSU
    • Grizzlies
    • UVU
    • SUU
    • Sports Wire
  • Sports Picks
Advertise with usReport this ad

BYU football: Craig Thompson letter says replay officials in BYU-SDSU game 'weren't sufficiently aggressive'

  • Print
  • Font [+] [-]
  • 91 Comments »

By Dick Harmon, Deseret News

Published: Tuesday, Nov. 2 2010 6:27 p.m. MDT

Photo
  • View 1 photo »
Summary

A private letter between MWC commissioner Criag Thompson and San Diego State President Stephen Weber obtained by San Diego media indicate the video replay crew working the Aztec football game with BYU Oct. 9 in LaVell Edwards Stadium "weren't sufficiently aggressive" enough in pointing out that conclusive video evidence on live TV showed a non-fumble call was wrong.

More Coverage
  • Hauck no stranger to Bronco

  • BYU reserves known by teammates

  • Cougars expect a war against UNLV

Following the game, Thompson said MWC officials told the crew replays existed that showed indisputable evidence of the fumble and the crew reported they had no knowledge of such a "look" and Angelis reaffirmed what he saw was not sufficient to rule it a fumble. The crew, according to the commissioner, spent 60 to 90 minutes after the game and reviewed the video that Angelis made his decision from and still did not "identify the definite replay."

Thompson's letter said after the game, the crew saw the available video and "were horrified to learn of their mistake."

According to the Union-Tribune, SDSU boosters said in their second letter to BYU's Samuelson that "we leave the fine points to the legal scholars schooled in the meaning of gross negligence."

"What is more shocking is that the national television (video)... replayed the questionable call over and over again," the boosters' new letter states.

"How was the withheld play not seen at that time and the replay (not) forwarded to the replay official?"

Last week, in response to SDSU boosters' call for a full investigation by BYU, BYU issued a statement that said all MWC protocol by the crew was followed in the game and that insinuations that there was wrongdoing were erroneous.

e-mail: dharmon@desnews.com

Related Stories
  • Hauck no stranger to Bronco

  • BYU reserves known by teammates

  • Cougars expect a war against UNLV

  • «Prev
  • Page:
  • 1
  • 2

Featured Comments

See all 91 comments »
Wallbanger
Spanish Fork, UT

Obviously this was a fumble, get over it, move on, who cares anymore...GO UTES!!

  • 6:44 p.m. Nov. 2, 2010
  • Top comment
RaininTime
Orem, UT

Awesome, SDSU is sending letters to BYU?

Send your letters to the MWC and while we are all sending letters and consulting lawyers, let's review every call that was ever made in error that should have been reversed, but wasn't.

I More..

  • 7:00 p.m. Nov. 2, 2010
  • Top comment
jazzbball
Salt Lake City, UT

I agree with Wallbanger. It was a fumble. It's also sour grapes by SDSU.
I like how SDSU glosses over the fact that these are MWC hired employees.
It's not like it was the last play of the game...
SDSU was thoroughly outplayed More..

  • 7:14 p.m. Nov. 2, 2010
  • Top comment
Comments
Leave a comment »

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
— About comments

About the Author
Dick Harmon

Dick Harmon

Dick Harmon is a columnist for the Deseret News with a focus on college athletics. He previously worked as executive sports editor, sports columnist, city editor and police reporter for the Provo Daily Herald for 26 more ..

  • Connect:
Advertise with usReport this ad
What You May Have Missed
  • No kid is an island: homeschool co-ops give social opportunities to children who learn at home
  • Life of prayer: Attitudes and beliefs about prayer evolve in old age
  • Watch a video tribute to Sister Frances J. Monson
Sample sports edition email
Advertise with usReport this ad
Most Popular
Across Site
In Sports
  • BYU, Utah and Utah State 2013 football...
  • BYU, Utah and Utah State 2013 football...
  • BYU basketball: Agustin Ambrosino leaves BYU...
  • High school baseball: Bingham Miners bring...
  • High school baseball: Salem Hills Skyhawks...
  • High school boys soccer: Lehi beats Bingham,...
  • High school boys soccer: Practice makes...
  • ESPN trivia guru: University of Utah graduate...
  • Sister Frances J. Monson's legacy of love...
  • Provo couple killed in RV accident near St....
  • LDS Church responds to Boy Scouts of...
  • Man charged with killing Ogden officer found...
  • BYU, Utah and Utah State 2013 football...
  • Police were watching, listening to Josh and...
  • Mormon Parenting: Don’t call gay unions...
  • Sintra, Portugal, is a perfect combination of...
Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

Facebook

Twitter

RSS

Email

Most Commented
Across Site
In Sports
  • High school baseball: 5A, 4A state... 56
  • Hard work, dedication pay off for... 56
  • BYU, Utah and Utah State 2013 football... 29
  • BYU basketball: Dave Rose hoping Tyler... 28
  • BYU basketball: Agustin Ambrosino... 28
  • Bodyguards allegedly beat up 2 fans who... 19
  • Utah Jazz: No lottery luck, so Jazz... 19
  • Utah State football: New coach Matt... 14
  • LDS Church responds to Boy Scouts of... 83
  • Chaffetz not willing to take... 70
  • Mormon Parenting: Don’t call gay... 67
  • Defending the Faith: A case for the... 64
  • Hard work, dedication pay off for... 56
  • High school baseball: 5A, 4A state... 56
  • BYU baseball: Cougars upset No. 13... 45
  • Boy Scouts open membership to all boys,... 44
Advertise with usReport this ad
Advertise with usReport this ad
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Moneywise
  • Opinion
  • Faith
  • Family
  • Obituaries
Home »
  • Blogs
  • Topics
  • Lists
  • Movies
  • Columnists
  • Watch It
News »
  • Utah news
  • World & Nation
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Education
  • Salt Lake County
  • Utah County
  • Davis County
  • Police/Courts
  • Legislature
  • Weather
  • Immigration
  • News Wire
Sports »
  • Utah Jazz
  • Sports Picks
  • BYU Cougars
  • Utah Utes
  • Utah State Aggies
  • Real Salt Lake
  • Salt Lake Bees
  • High school sports
  • Rock
  • Harmon
  • Watch It
  • Scores and Stats
  • On TV
  • NFL
  • MLB
  • Weber State Wildcats
  • Grizzlies
  • Utah Valley Wolverines
  • Southern Utah University
  • Sports Wire
Opinion »
  • Editorials
  • Op-Eds
  • Letters
  • Political Cartoons
Faith »
  • Featured Faiths
  • Mormon Times
  • LDS Church News
  • Mission Reunions
  • Faith Wire
Family »
  • Marriage & Parenting
  • Family Media
  • Movie Guide
  • Calendar
  • TV Listings
  • Family Life Wire
Special Sections »
  • Education Week
  • LDS General Conference
  • Mormons in America
  • Olympics
  • Outdoor Retailer
  • Rugby
  • Sports Picks
  • Sundance Film Festival
  • Utah Blaze
  • Utah Grizzlies
  • Print Subscription
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • FAQ
  • Feedback
  • Jobs
  • RSS
  • E-Edition
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Legal notices
  • Advertise with us
Advertise with usReport this ad