Bennett, Matheson face unusual political dynamics

To the surprise of many people (but not to delegates or campaign insiders), Sen. Bob Bennett faces a very stiff challenge in the May 8 GOP convention, and Congressman JimMatheson will have to work to fend off his challenger. Popular incumbents rarely face such opposition within their own parties, especially in Utah politics. We explore questions surrounding these unusual dynamics.

Why are political activists in both political parties so agitated this year, and how is it impacting the races?

Pignanelli: "CNBC's Rick Santelli is the 'father' of the tea party movement." — The Daily Caller

(That's right. Italians named our country and the modern anti-government force ... You're welcome!) Although the tea party movement is rather small in Utah, something is happening inside the local Republican Party. GOP insiders say at least 75 percent of the 2010 convention delegates are new (the usual turnover rate is about 33 percent). This is a direct result of the high turnout at the March 23 Republican precinct caucuses, where delegates were chosen. There are strong whispers among politicos about delegate polls placing Bennett with less than the 40 percent needed to emerge from the convention, and Tim Bridgewater and Mike Lee moving to the primary. This is an amazing scenario.

Although conservatives have hated the federal government for generations, a stagnant economy and "reprieve" of Wall Street crooks is fostering emotions to a higher level. So far, the screams from the right have garnered limited results in dumping perceived moderate Republican incumbents. But Utah may be their first real success. For a number of reasons, Bennett is the focus of tea party and other ultraconservative ire across the country. Well-financed organizations outside Utah are dumping resources against Bennett. The senator's strong ability to secure federal assistance for a number of important Utah projects is now a campaign burden. "Anyone but Bennett" is a rallying cry for a large number of delegates. Veteran politicos are shaking their heads in wonder.

No matter the political cost, left of center Democrats want Matheson to support Obama administration programs. His refusal is generating emotions within their ranks. In response, Matheson is securing support of most Democratic officials to build a firewall against his feisty intraparty opponent Claudia Wright. A quick study, Matheson hopes to prevent a similar anti-incumbent movement in his party.