Air standards ever changing
This time of year, when inversions trap dirty air in Utah's valleys, it's obvious that Utahns should do more to improve air quality.
In many respects, Utah has made considerable improvements in air quality due to the advent of cleaner burning fuels and high performance automobile engines. Few people or businesses burn coal for heat anymore. Public transportation, particularly light rail and commuter rail, has taken a considerable number of cars off the road.
Some of the improvements were the result of federal laws that set attainment benchmarks. These have largely been changes for the better.
But the Environmental Protection Agency's continual tinkering with the standards and its "proposed disapproval" of the state's plan to monitor and bring under control particulate matter pollution have frustrated state regulators. It's almost as if the state has entered a five-mile race, only to learn the finish line has been moved another mile. Or as Ernie Wessman, chairman of the state's air quality control board, lamented at a recent meeting of the group, "It's like having to follow a rule you don't know exists."
Not only is this frustrating from a regulation standpoint, federal transportation dollars are on the line.
Other than natural and exceptional events such as dust storms, fireworks displays or smoke from wildfires, Utah has been able to keep PM10 levels below the EPA's 24-hour standards established in 2005 — even during the worst winter inversions.
Two years later, the agency enacted a new rule that says "natural and exceptional" events have to be included in required counts, even if they push the rolling average above acceptable standards.
No wonder state regulators are at wits end. State and local governments could, conceivably, impose strict regulations about fireworks displays. But they have no control over natural events that pollute the air such as wildfires or dust storms. To threaten federal transportation funds — some of which include funding for mass transit — seems shortsighted.
The state air quality control board plans to send a letter to EPA officials explaining why it feels the state's plan still meets the criteria that was in play when it was submitted five years ago. Federal officials need to take time to consider the unique characteristics of the Mountain West and the state's earnest efforts to reach federal standards that, over the years, have become more stringent.
Recent comments
It's funny hearing American's complain about consumption, seeing that...
Randy | Feb. 9, 2010 at 6:43 p.m.
Beans | 4:04 p.m.
Conservatives aren't the only ones who
object...
Hint to "Beans | 4:04 p.m. " | Feb. 9, 2010 at 4:52 p.m.
To "point "A" to point "B" | 8:23 a.m. " but fuel economy is only...
RedShirt | Feb. 9, 2010 at 4:41 p.m.
- Decorative paint a alternative 1:32 p.m.
- Stocks trade flat on China inflation 1:31 p.m.
- Court upholds Pledge's 'under God' 1:30 p.m.
- Fire prompts Tooele town evacuation 1:25 p.m.
- Skirting styling below the waist? 1:22 p.m.
- The bulb revolution 1:17 p.m.
- Treasures: 100 years and counting 1:13 p.m.
- Aggie great Merlin Olsen dies at 69 1:09 p.m.
- Living in a dorm, but not students 1:06 p.m.
- Blog: Celebrating motherhood —... 1:05 p.m.
- BYU's Hall, Pitta show off for NFL
- Y. 1st on U.S. News most popular
- Aggie great Merlin Olsen dies at 69
- Prom off after gay student's request
- Utah crashes leave 4 dead
- BYU aims to win MWC Tournament
- Utahn fights for health insurance
- D-Will, Boozer enjoy short respite
- Man allegedly steals with store items
- Williams leads Jazz over Pistons
- Hobson edges Fredette for POY
206 - Are Utah charter schools a success?
186 - Health care a human wish, not right
156 - Prom off after gay student's request
146 - Services for Marie Osmond's son
132 - Student argues with officers over gun
125 - LDS, S.L. work to transform land
118 - Bryce Valley captures first title
108 - Teacher questions tattoo dress code
106 - Letters: Pushing atheist views
104
Interesting and entertaining observations of the Utah Legislature.
So if Max Hall came to coach at Utah would that mean that Max would hate...
Ric: "Utah will NEVER compete with the bigger WEST teams on the glass with...
Healthcare? Yes, please.
...will be cheering for the Utes today! Go Utes, go Air Force, and GO COUGARS!
'You think it bad now, wait until the government takes it over.' - 1:06 p.m....
So your saying one day all school bathrooms and locker rooms will be unisex,...
Pitta wont be the first MWC player chosen, Jerry Hughes and Daryl Washington...
How come this article doesn't mention BYU's dominance over Utah in basketball...
Attending the prom is not a human right. It is a social event. No one is...
WASHINGTON–Following the launch of a Justice Department criminal probe...




