From Deseret News archives:

Elegy

Published: Monday, Sept. 1, 2008 8:55 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
There are few, more-frustrating actors than Ben Kingsley. Since he won an Academy Award for his portrayal of "Gandhi" in 1983, he's given a series of performances that can charitably be described as phoning-it-in or workman-like.

And yet every once in a while he'll give the type of performance, like his superb lead turn in the drama "Elegy," that reminds you of just how great he can be when he's properly motivated.

Kingsley is also part of a rock-solid acting ensemble that makes this faulty adaptation of Philip Roth's novel "The Dying Animal" better than it should be.

He stars as David Kepesh, a cultural critic and college professor who's been going from one fling to another ever since he left his marriage years ago.

Recently, Kepesh has become attracted to Consuela Castillo (Penelope Cruz), an alluring student. But he waits to make his move until she finishes her work in his class.

The two start dating, and he begins acting like a jealous, possessive school boy. Even Kepesh's womanizing poet pal, George O'Hearn (Dennis Hopper), is astonished by the change in his friend's demeanor and behavior.

Story continues below
Director Isabel Coixet ("My Life Without Me") and veteran screenwriter Nicholas Meyer struggle to get a grasp on the material. They've had to compress and combine certain elements (there's only so much time in a film to deal with things like male-female relationships, as well as maturity and immaturity).

Also, it's a little episodic, and the ending is too rushed. A subplot dealing with Kepesh's adult son, played by Peter Sarsgard, feels very half-hearted as well.

It is still a decent vehicle for Kingsley, though. The crafty actor makes the relationship between Kepesh and Castillo achingly real. Cruz is quite good as his much-younger lover. She almost deserves her own movie.

And so does the "sex buddy" character that's played by Patricia Clarkson. She and a surprisingly restrained, subtle Hopper are both terrific, in limited screen time.

"Elegy" is rated R for scenes of simulated sex and other sexual contact, female nudity, some strong sexual language (profanity and other suggestive talk), and slurs and other derogatory language. Running time: 108 minutes.


E-MAIL: jeff@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Bring the true spirit of Christmas

All I want for Christmas is a good health care bill. From either party - I...

As a BYU fan after seeing Tim Tebow react after he did playing in the Bama...

Letters: Preening president

mark | 11:17 p.m Obama never said that. Obama did say he would take advice...

BCS crazy, you don't know what you are talking about. Go hawks!!!

I don't know Mr. Valdez, but I do know a couple members of his family. If I...

Utahns want health care reform bills

I want one thing explained to me before I will consider any of your...

Letters: Report the news

"The U.K. Met Office says it will release weather data next week for the...

Sheepman fighting to save flock

Have any of you (2009, stop grazing, perfect solution,perfect mess,...

Why hasn't BYU practiced this week? Well ... it might be so some players...

Letters: Report the news

I guess fair and balanced reporting by conservative shills as omitted that...

Advertisements