From Deseret News archives:

Diary of a Mad Black Woman

Published: Thursday, Feb. 24, 2005 1:58 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
"Diary of a Mad Black Woman" can't figure out what kind of movie it wants to be. At times, its melodramatic story lines appear to have been taken directly from a daytime soap opera. At others, it's filled with shrill, madcap antics that could have come from a UPN sitcom.

Which is not to say that a film can't have a blend of comedy and drama. But the blend doesn't work when they're both done to ridiculous extremes, as they are here.

"Diary" is a dreadful showcase for actress Kimberly Elise, who has impressed in other films, most notably last year's remake of "The Manchurian Candidate." She stars as Helen McCarter, a pampered Atlanta housewife.

Helen seems to have it all, including a perfect marriage to wealthy attorney Charles McCarter (Steve Harris). However, he throws Helen for a loop when he kicks her out of the house and moves his mistress in.

With nowhere to go, Helen moves in with her estranged, gun-packing, fast-talking Aunt Madea (Tyler Perry, in one of three roles), who encourages her to go on with her life — including taking a chance with Orlando (Shemar Moore), a hunky steel-plant worker with a heart of gold.

To say that this material is predictable is an understatement. Director Darren Grant and screenwriter Perry (who adapted one of his "Madea" plays here) also throw in treacly sentiments by the bucketload.

Story continues below
As unconvincing as the dramatic aspects of the story are, they're nothing compared to the painful, supposed comic bits, most featuring Perry in drag. About the only people who will find them funny are those eagerly anticipating "Big Momma's House 2."

As for Elise, her performance is very tentative. It's as if she's not sure whether her character is supposed to be likable at all, and her chemistry with both Moore and Harris is non-existent.

Still, the primary irritant here is Perry, whose performance is the cinematic equivalent of listening to fingernails scrape a chalkboard for two hours.

"Diary of a Mad Black Woman" is rated PG-13 for violence (some slapstick, as well as a shooting), drug content (talk of drug-dealing and some pot smoking), scattered use of strong profanity, and use of some crude slang terms, as well as a flatulence gag. Running time: 116 minutes.


E-MAIL: jeff@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Movie Info
Rated PG13 for profanity, vulgarity, drug use.

Cast: Kimberly Elise, Steve Harris, Shemar Moore
FIND LOCAL MOVIE SHOWTIMES
Image
Alfeo Dixon, Lions Gate Films

Kimberly Elise plays cast-off housewife in "Diary of Mad Black Woman."

previousnext

Latest comments

Demos' losses could rise

Wow! Two, count 'em-two!-dumb dem congressmen. Sounds like a landslide...

Sink baby sink! American Senators....do the right thing.....crush this...

Very innovative - This should change the industry. Hope it happens early on...

Reducing game time laughable

Is parents living vicariously through their kids. The kids want a balanced...

park city is gunna kill hurricane

Poor backers of greedy insurance companies still spreading fear and lies to...

TCU 52 Utah 3

As much as the Jazz and fans anticipate these two coming back the reality is...

Let's see, Utah barely beats Air Force and Wyoming, a team BYU killed 52-0,...

Hey Sorenson do you think Oklahoma's 4 loss year could have anything to do...

Advertisements
Advertisement