From Deseret News archives:

I, Robot

Published: Thursday, July 15, 2004 12:01 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
To its credit, "I, Robot" does try to be a more cerebral summer movie; the thinking man's version, if you will. And it does so by daring to introduce some fairly thought-provoking concepts.

Of course, that makes it all the more disappointing when the film becomes just another big, dumb, loud action movie over the course of its second half — and especially when some of the trickier plot points are resolved in an easy, fairly brainless fashion. (Actually, for a film that apparently prides itself on its smarts, there's some contrived and conventional plotting at work here.)

Unfortunately, in the end, what will be remembered is how disappointing a treatment this is of some pretty revered source material. Though it takes its name from just one of them, "I, Robot" was inspired by a series of stories by late author Isaac Asimov.

Story continues below
Will Smith stars in this futuristic science-fiction thriller as Del Spooner, a Chicago homicide detective who has a prejudice against what he terms needless technology, in particular robotic life forms. Ironically, his latest case finds him investigating the death of Alfred Lanning (James Cromwell), the world's foremost robotics expert. While others are suggesting Lanning's death was suicide, Del believes the victim was killed by one of his own creations, an android that calls itself "Sonny" (a CGI creation featuring the voice of actor Alan Tudyk).

However, "laws" programmed into each robot are supposed to prevent such a thing, so Del finds himself butting heads with the CEO of the robotics company (Bruce Greenwood), who may have something to hide. So, Del enlists the help of Susan Calvin (Bridget Moynahan), one of Lanning's prize pupils. And cryptic clues also seem to come from beyond the grave, and from the primary suspect.

Curiously, Alex Proyas's direction seems a little flat. The same goes for the performances — it's ironic that the most robotic acting comes from those who are playing human characters (particularly Moynahan).

Smith is considerably livelier — better here than he's been in a while. But you do have to wonder if he has improvised at least some of his own one-liners, considering how little humor there is otherwise.

Digital Domain's CGI effects are convincing and look good. Some of the credit for that should go to production designer Patrick Tatopoulos.

"I, Robot" is rated PG-13 for scenes of sci-fi/action violence (gunfire, robot attacks and explosive mayhem), occasional use of strong profanity, gore (mostly in photos), brief partial male nudity (a shower scene) and use of some crude slang terms. Running time: 115 minutes.


E-MAIL: jeff@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Movie Info
Rated PG13 for gore, profanity, vulgarity, brief partial nudity.

Cast: Will Smith, Bridget Moynahan, Bruce Greenwood
FIND LOCAL MOVIE SHOWTIMES
Image
Digital Domain

On the hunt for a murderer, homicide detective Del Spooner (Will Smith) takes a close look at one of several thousand suspects in "I, Robot."

previousnext

Latest comments

Again, why can't the left understand that WE CANNOT AFFORD THIS! Why can't...

Danica is absolutely amazing!! And so is Mckell. They played so good! Do they...

One Vote??? This sounds a bit dirty to me...the odds are virtually...

Bennett's anti-Obama TV ad

There's no such thing as a RINO anymore because all the Republican Party...

Hmm... the Dixie golf state champ and the SC volleyball state champ live in...

Water wars in Snake Valley

Look for a real solution. Taking water from a desert is insane! What...

Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings

.....tell this sub was gonna sink? Why do you think he bailed out!

Letters: Salaries questionable

Network engineer. Absolutely brilliant, he did not learn his skills in...

Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings

Why do you think Gordon Chiasa and Hot Rod Bailed out! This ship has been...

'However, contrary to what appears to be the opinion held by some here,...

Advertisements
Advertisement