From Deseret News archives:

Panic Room

Published: Friday, March 29, 2002 8:00 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
David Fincher comes closer than ever to getting everything right with "Panic Room."

Fincher's filmography to date has become a rather frustrating experience because even his best works — "The Game" and "Fight Club" — have irritating flaws (either in plot, story structure or characterization) that prevent them from reaching greatness.

The same could also be said of his latest, a suspense-thriller that again features Fincher's characteristically startling visual style and an almost palpable sense of intensity (if you're not gripping your armrests through this one, you'd better check your pulse).

But as usual, the film is relatively character-thin and ends with a real thud — not one bad enough to ruin the movie, but it may make you wonder what might the film have been with just one more script revision.

"Panic Room" refers to a hiding place in the new home of Manhattanite Meg Altman (Jodie Foster), who is separated from her wealthy husband and has been looking for a safe home for herself and her teenage daughter Sarah (Kristen Stewart).

Story continues below
And few homes would be safer than this brownstone. For one thing, it's got a hidden room that's surrounded by concrete and has its own air and power supplies, as well as a row of video monitors.

As it turns out, that room comes in real handy during their first night in the house. That's when a trio of robbers (Forest Whitaker, Dwight Yoakam and Jared Leto, sporting a corn-row hairstyle) decide to break in. Meg quickly gets herself and Sarah into the room, but she also leaves her cell phone behind. Through the home's intercom system, she's able to communicate with the crooks, who inform her that the object they're searching for is actually in that room.

Throughout the film, Fincher makes numerous allusions to Hitchcock, especially the dazzling city skyline title credits and Howard Shore's Bernard Herrmann-like score. And the eye-popping camera work — by Oscar-winner Conrad Hall and Darius Knondji — clearly pays tribute to Orson Welles (watch for several "how'd-they-do-that?" tricks that Welles would have loved).

Fincher has also paced the film well, helping cover up some of the obvious holes in David Koepp's clever but superficial script, which fails to make Meg as interesting a character as the criminals — especially Whitaker's surprisingly sympathetic security expert. Foster doesn't help, as she's patrician and aloof (although, in her defense, she did replace Nicole Kidman at the 11th hour, when Kidman dropped out with a "Moulin Rouge" injury).

"Panic Room" is rated R for violence (gunplay and beatings), occasional use of strong sexual profanity, gore, use of crude sexual slang, drug content (hypodermics) and a brief scene of torture. Running time: 108 minutes.


E-MAIL: jeff@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Movie Info
Rated R for violence, gore, profanity, vulgarity, drugs.

Cast: Jodie Foster, Forest Whitaker, Kristen Stewart, Jared Leto
FIND LOCAL MOVIE SHOWTIMES
previousnext

Latest comments

Watch out for my H-TOWN brothers there gonna be dunking on some fools this...

Hall reprimanded by MWC

I lived through the Lavell Edwards era at BYU, so I know what it's like to be...

just leave it to media to make a mountain out of a mole hill. to heap extra...

Chaffetz: Leave Afghanistan

Jason, stop asking Miss California for advice on war.

Religion in politics is tiresome

It cracks me up when religionists demand an explanation for every facet of...

Religion in politics is tiresome

Christy et al, So, you THINK that we have a representative government?...

Mike, The Utes and the Aggies don't play again until 2012. Maybe the Ags...

Mike, The Utes and the Aggies don't play again until 2012. Maybe the Ags...

Who cares about the trash talk between Utah and Y? The Kitties are coming to...

if any thing Hall showed he was selfish. He took the spotlight off of George...

Advertisements