From Deseret News archives:

One Night at McCool's

Published: Friday, April 27, 2001 8:04 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Since the comedic standard has been lowered considerably, and given that audiences are starved for a really good comedy, you'd think that something different, like "One Night at McCool's," might stand a chance.

But that also assumes that this dark comedy — which borrows heavily from one of Akira Kurosawa's masterpieces, as well as the noir films of the '40s — could live up to the standards set by those sources, albeit in some tiny way.

Unfortunately, "McCool's" can't even do that. Instead, it's a full-on, mean-spirited bore that's neither as sexy nor as smart as it thinks it is. And at times, it's also rather violent (including an attempted rape scene that's in extremely bad taste).

But of all the cinematic sins committed by the film, perhaps the biggest is its criminal misuse of a pretty decent cast. That includes Matt Dillon, who stars as Randy, a somewhat dim-witted Missouri bartender unlucky enough to have met the gorgeous but larcenous Jewel (Liv Tyler, who appears to be aping Marilyn Monroe).

Within minutes of their first meeting, this femme fatale quickly sinks her claws into Randy, framing him for the killing of her ex (Andrew Silverstein, better known as Andrew Dice Clay) and making him her accomplice in crime.

Story continues below
But blinded by love (or lust, to be more accurate), he agrees to go along with her plans for "domesticity," even while Jewel has been busy ensnaring others in her web — including Randy's sleazy lawyer cousin (Paul Reiser, more irritating than usual) and the detective who's hot on their trail (John Goodman).

One thing that would have helped the film right off the bat would have been to drop the "different perspectives" plot device (shades of "Rashomon"), which isn't funny, and which will go over most moviegoers' heads.

Also, it's hard to say which is more strident here, the broad characterizations, Harald Zwart's heavy-handed direction or yet another awful Marc Shaiman score (this one reinforcing the film's "humor").

Of the cast, the only one who really seems to be having much fun is executive producer/co-star Michael Douglas, who sports an awful hairpiece and dental appliances, but whose character is underused.

"One Night at McCool's" is rated R for frequent use of strong profanity, violence (gunfire, as well as violence against women), crude sexual humor, simulated sex, gore and a brief scene depicting a sexual assault. Running time: 93 minutes.


E-MAIL: jeff@desnews.com

Recent comments

Good movie. Funny situations, good plot turns, and great
eye-candy...

Julie | July 2, 2001 at 4:15 p.m.

Brad Pitt and Julia Roberts are always fun to watch on the
big...

Eve Ross | March 13, 2001 at 4:04 p.m.

I LOVE BRAD PITT. THIS IS ANOTHER GREAT MOVIE WITH HIS
HANDSOME...

RACHEL | March 12, 2001 at 7:45 p.m.

Movie Info
Rated R for violence, gore, profanity, vulgarity, sex.

Cast: Matt Dillon, Liv Tyler, Michael Douglas, John Goodman, Paul Reiser, Reba McEntire, Andrew Silverstein, Richard Jenkins
FIND LOCAL MOVIE SHOWTIMES
previousnext

Latest comments

U.N. climate conference opens

To read and believe most of the previously posted comments would make one...

We are still in a recession. This "nutbag" creates a LOT of well paying jobs...

TCU's BCS game missing something

whats wrong with Florida vs TCU and Boise St. vs Cinci... these two teams...

how convenient for the bcs powers. they can say they took two no bcs teams,...

Grad rates between blacks, whites

It is unfortunate most black athletes probably come from inner cities with...

There you go, Boone Pickens is a wily old coyote, who has Queen Nancy on the...

MVPs wrap up stellar prep careers

The problem, Hart, as good as he might be, became a product of an offense...

Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil

This is a sports battle; a great rivalry; this can not just be swept away....

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

Glenn Beck is saying a lot of things the media is ignoring (and Americans are...

TCU's BCS game missing something

You have to admit that this was a very smart move for the BCS boys. You...

Advertisements