From Deseret News archives:

Plunkett & Macleane

Published: Thursday, Oct. 7, 1999 3:01 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Rarely has 18th-century England looked as unappealing as it does it "Plunkett & Macleane."

Yet ironically enough, the film itself is nearly irresistible — at least for an hour, which is when the whole thing collapses under the weight of a too-serious approach, bad plotting and truly odd contemporary touches that make the film seem more like a fantasy than a historically based adventure.

Still, it's not a terrible filmmaking debut for Jake Scott, whose father (Ridley Scott, of "Alien" and "Thelma & Louise" fame) and uncle (Tony Scott, "Crimson Tide," "Top Gun") have both made their marks in the cinematic world with similarly flashy but inconsistent works (in terms of material).

Unfortunately, it is the material that fails the younger Scott and a pretty decent cast, which includes "Trainspotting" co-stars Robert Carlyle and Jonny Lee Miller as the title characters, a pair of real-life highwaymen who robbed some of England's richest and most prominent citizens.

The two men meet when Plunkett (Carlyle) accidentally frees Macleane (Miller) from debtor's prison. Later on, as the two wind up imprisoned for grave robbing, they become extremely reluctant partners in crime.

Story continues below
After buying their release, the duo begins a new scheme, one to set up Macleane as a faux nobleman — so he can find rich and easy targets to rob. Meanwhile, Plunkett, playing the role of his faithful servant, provides the know-how and arms to pull off their daring thefts.

Word quickly spreads about these "gentlemen highwaymen," who are courteous to their victims and who manage to evade capture by the cruel Mr. Chance (Ken Stott). They even become folk heroes of sorts to the less fortunate.

Eventually the two men do obtain enough money to sail to America, where they hope to find more respectable professions. But Macleane finds himself increasingly drawn to the beautiful Lady Rebecca Gibson (Liv Tyler), which may spell disaster for all of them.

Scott definitely has his father's eye for eye-popping visuals. And he keeps the action moving so fast that the dumb plotting and inconsistent characterizations aren't quite as glaring as they might have been.

But the script (by a trio of British screenwriters) is lacking enough humor and grimy charm. Also, you have to wonder what signal the filmmakers are trying to send by making these two characters out to be heroes.

However, there is good chemistry between Miller and Carlyle, and Tyler certainly doesn't embarrass herself — although her British accent wavers in places.

"Plunkett and Macleane" is rated R for violent gunplay and explosions, profanity, simulated sex, some extremely crude humor and use of vulgar sexual slang terms, gore and a scene of torture.

Recent comments

I haven't watched the movie but the play by Rattigan is
simply...

Itishree | Nov. 12, 2002 at 6:23 a.m.

While the movie started out slow--"Do you really want to
keep...

David Williams | June 29, 2002 at 1:07 a.m.

A splendid, well-crafted stage play effectively transferred
to the...

Dennis Orgill | Oct. 10, 1999 at 3:37 p.m.

Movie Info
Rated R for violence, gore, profanity, vulgarity, brief nudity, sex, , racial epithets, .

Cast: Jonny Lee Miller, Robert Carlyle, Liv Tyler
FIND LOCAL MOVIE SHOWTIMES
previousnext

Latest comments

'Ham' operator helps with rescue

Yes, Amatuer Radio operators are called Hams.....

So we're expanding the Medicare program that is underfunded by...

U.N.: '00-'09 warmest decade

Redistribution of wealth and power is good. It will get us off foreign oil...

BYU eager for crack at Oregon State

OSU will be very very tough. As a PAC-10 (and BYU) fan with degrees from UW...

Government incompetence drives up the unemployment rate. Lower taxes drives...

More government waste and lies. Government Motors bailout of the unions...

How many times has BYU appeared in a post-season bowl game only to lose to an...

BCS reform still needed

I am sure the BCS, with their unlimited resources, used their magic time...

U.N.: '00-'09 warmest decade

Global lies and another hunt for power and our money. Government continues...

Is there anything you wouldn't do for money?

Advertisements