From Deseret News archives:

Unload iProvo, critic urges

Published: Thursday, April 17, 2008 12:53 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PROVO — Better to privatize iProvo now and end the bleeding than lose another estimated $2 million over the next year, a longtime critic of the city-owned fiber optic network said Wednesday.

Steven Titch of the Reason Foundation — a Los Angeles-based think tank that promotes libertarian principles — issued a eight-page policy brief that highlighted what he terms "iProvo's poor performance." Titch, a policy analyst specializing in telecommunications for the Reason Foundation, blasted the city's telecommunication network, saying municipal governments have no place in the high-tech infrastructure business.

"They don't do it well," he said. "And iProvo is an example of this."

Provo issued $39.5 million in bonds to finance the construction of iProvo. Since its inception, the network has experienced high churn rates among subscribers and relied heavily on subsidies to keep afloat. To date, the project has cost the city $8.4 million, Titch said, and there are projections iProvo will cost another $2 million. He sees only two options.

"Provo now faces the dilemma of continuing to fund iProvo with no break-even point in sight," Titch wrote. "Or sell the property and recoup as much of its investment as it can."

Story continues below
Provo spokeswoman Helen Anderson responded Wednesday saying the report is flawed throughout, and added the churn rates are not unusually high in comparison to other telecommunication companies. She said city officials had other problems with the report.

City Councilman George Stewart said he reviewed the report and found it a pretty accurate commentary on iProvo's current situation. Although the system provides the best broadband in the city, he's not sure it's worth subsidizing to the extent the city has gone.

"(Privatization) would be my preferred option because it would be a win-win," he said.

This report isn't the first iProvo critique offered by Titch and the Reason Foundation. The foundation issued another report by Titch in Dec. 5, 2006, that lambasted iProvo.

Among the findings in the 2006 report, Titch stated that iProvo was behind on its business plan and would continue to be forced to borrow money; iProvo's wholesale plan depended heavily on the performance of its retail partners; retail pricing for services using iProvo was not substantially different enough to prompt consumers to migrate away from service providers like Comcast and Qwest Communications; and iProvo was not contributing significantly to the growth of broadband in Provo.

Recent comments

I agree with Andrew. iProvo was a great idea from the very beginning...

It Starts at the TOP | April 21, 2008 at 6:04 p.m.

Throw out option 2 as a cure for the ailing iProvo. Requiring City...

Nvnospin | April 18, 2008 at 9:10 a.m.

I fully support iProvo for the reasons stated above. It is a good...

Doug J | April 17, 2008 at 2:06 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

The terrible thing is that if this passes, more people would be helped....

It is David's decision to go on a mission or not, however..... you just...

So. Sevier gives Waterford 1st loss

The Rams will fold like they did in football.

Tethering of pets could spur charges

The sweet little doggy picture on this article is part of all the propaganda...

strange question...why did it take over a month to report this.. Best wishes...

I have seen several young men in our Stake pressured into something they are...

My vote is for Ben McAdams.

Woods voted athlete of the decade

Not only is golf a sport (and golfers athletes), but it takes FAR more skill,...

Josh Powell meets with WVC police

"And FYI, the presumption of innocence is not in the Constitution. Maybe YOU...

Miles why don`t you grow up. You post several times a day,using many names...

Advertisements