From Deseret News archives:

News is asking wrong theater question

Published: Monday, March 31, 2008 12:32 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Where should the new Broadway-style theater in Salt Lake County be built? That was the implicit question posed in Erica Hansen's front-page article in last Sunday's paper. According to her, the answer is clear: "Those asked by the Deseret Morning News, except for Sandy's Mayor Tom Dolan and the project developer, almost universally agreed — downtown is the place."

I respectfully note that she certainly didn't ask me. Nor did she ask any of the members of the growing South Valley Arts Alliance, a community group consisting of residents from all over Salt Lake County who fervently support the Sandy city theater project.

In any case, I believe that the Deseret Morning News is, in fact, asking the wrong question. Unfortunately, it's the question that has driven most of the media coverage about this project, and both of Salt Lake's major papers have had no shortage of harsh words for both Sandy city and her mayor. The driving narrative has been that Sandy is essentially stealing something that rightfully belongs to Salt Lake City.

But this isn't a city project. This theater is being built with private funds.

Contrast this with the Sandy soccer stadium, which required a significant outlay of taxpayer money from both the county and the state. In that instance, elected officials from both bodies had a legitimate voice in how public resources should be used.

Story continues below
But this time around, county and state officials aren't being asked for a dime. So it's presumptuous of either the county or the state — or the Deseret Morning News, for that matter — to suggest that Sandy city needs their permission to move forward.

It's worth noting that nobody is making any attempt to prevent Salt Lake City from building any theater of any kind, either downtown or anywhere else. Sandy is not standing in the way. The stark reality is that the resources to make a downtown theater happen just aren't there.

Studies have been conducted, and all of them have concluded that a theater downtown would be wildly expensive — and that taxpayers would be forced to foot the bill.

Once again the Utah Theater is being considered as a possible location, but that would require tens of millions of taxpayer dollars just to bring that building up to code, without additional enhancements. Throw in parking considerations and other logistical challenges, and Salt Lake City is back at square one, regardless of what Sandy city does or does not do.

Recent comments

It seems to me that many of the negative comments are coming from SLC...

kemmer | April 12, 2008 at 12:58 a.m.

I think this is the best thing that could happen to my community....

Rob | April 2, 2008 at 11:37 p.m.

One other comment: Sandy will be using tax payer dollars also. The...

jeannie | April 1, 2008 at 4:10 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

I'm sure the Yewts are not posting here any longer. Reason: TCU 35, Yewts 7.

Utes excited for 'dream' game

how's that game going for you guys? And I thought BYU looked really bad...

Let's start with the military. If we were to eliminate the bulk of the...

No. 22 BYU holds off pesky Lobos

Another silly Saturday in the 801. Y'all crack a Gator up.

are slowing down. hmmmm, anything to do with a mouthful of humble pie????

5A: Missed chances doom Alta

Alta fan, when you wrote this, "Hope fully the hawks have a great season next...

Good grief Cougs WTG TCU!! Now that is the way to represent the Conference....

I guesss I'll root for TCU

TCU= cure for Ute arrogance! Humble pie taste good?

All you ute fans who think you are so much better than BYU. Have you checked...

Advertisements
Advertisement