From Deseret News archives:

State denies any cover-up over Kennecott tailings pond

Published: Friday, March 28, 2008 12:49 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The 1997 document, written by former Kennecott chief legal officer Ray D. Gardner, does highlight seismic stability problems with the old 5,700-acre south impoundment's southeast corner, a section of the now-retired tailings pond. According to Gardner's findings, the impoundment failed in 1941 and 1964, each time due to water intrusion.

The Gardner document also says that in 1989 Frank Joklik, then-Kennecott president, disagreed with a suggestion that Kennecott should disclose to Magna residents the apparent seismic risk at the tailings pond. Gardner wrote that Joklik felt disclosure would cause "panic and suits."

Still, Gardner concluded in 1997, "Prior management's decisions to disregard and conceal legal advice, forgo public notice, attempt to establish a residential buffer surreptitiously, collude with the state engineer to withhold the KL studies from the public, and restrict the distribution of the Reduction Study, collectively and individually, give the appearance of a conspiracy to cover up a profound threat to public safety."

Lisa Roskelley, spokeswoman for Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr., said Thursday that the governor is committed to the health and safety of all Utahns and that state regulators will continue working with Kennecott and Magna officials to ensure the safety of the city's residents.

Story continues below
Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff's spokesman Paul Murphy said officials in his department have been talking this week about whether an investigation into Kennecott's past and the alleged cover-up issue is needed at this point, who would initiate and handle such an investigation, whether it would be a criminal or civil matter or even if the attorney general should be involved at all.

Gardner also wrote about how Joklik authorized his company's land arm to begin buying up houses that appeared to be most at risk from a flow of tailings if the earthen embankment at the Magna Corner failed during an earthquake.

Marlene Norcross, who did not want to sell at the time, said Thursday that her main concern at the time was getting Kennecott to control the problem with blowing tailings dust that would turn day into night on windy days. What might happen to the tailings in a strong earthquake was less of a concern to her than the impact of the quake on her home.

"I figured I be buried by a rock," she said about liquefication that would come with a strong quake.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Me and the Mrs. was thinkin' about comin' down to SLC to do a little...

Utes won't respond to Hall

Any unsportsman like conduct is wrong no matter who you our. And as someone...

Cougs begin bowl preparations

I live in Wyoming and fans here hate BYU with a passion, and would love to...

BCS stable at top, Y. up to 14

I'm with you! utwingnut

U. eyes bowl for redemption

Utes don't lose bowl games. Hopefully it's against a challenging team.

Utes won't respond to Hall

Max Hall said, blah blah. Ute fans don't want to talk about the real issue....

Editorial: East, West and religion

The Moslems should welcome free speech. How is their society ever to progress...

I'm a Ute fan and I don't hate Max Hall. I admit that when I first heard his...

I am a BYU fan and bleed blue, But Utah played a better game Saturday, we...

Good and thoughtful article, Amy. Max's lack of wisdom in his comments...

Advertisements