From Deseret News archives:

Dumping traditional school boards could save education

Published: Sunday, March 9, 2008 12:08 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
No matter the political persuasion of people, it is generally agreed the boat of public education has serious leaks. The disagreement is over the right solution to patch those leaks.

I advocate what may seem like a radical approach. The solution is not to deprive the schools and teachers of the funding they desperately need, nor is it to privatize the system. Rather, my aim is in directly tackling the bloated bureaucracy of public education. I don't want to fix it, and I don't want to build on it.

I want to remove it entirely.

The biggest complaints about public education from the parental side tend to focus on perceived problems with the curriculum and the quality of teaching. Historically, organizations such as the PTA have allowed parents to hold a direct, if somewhat minor, role in the classroom. However, parent-teacher alliances are decreasing both in quantity and in influence. Simply put, parents feel shut out from their own children's education.

On the other hand, teachers face issues of their own: increasing class sizes, little curriculum control, a burdensome bureaucracy, a salary that is simply far below what they deserve and dwindling parental involvement.

Story continues below
Many things keep the problems from being resolved — from federal encroachment to self-serving legislatures — but most of all, the problem lies with the bureaucracy of school boards.

The average salary of members of county school boards is well into six figures. And for what? What benefit are they to the system? They control curriculum, discourage parental involvement, limit teachers' influence over their own classrooms and encourage a system of "teaching to the test," which ensures that the students look good on paper but learn little.

So let's rid the system of them.

Obviously there would still need to be a board able to exercise oversight of the schools, but who better to exercise that oversight than the school administrators and the parents? Let's create not one but three distinct countywide boards for each level of education: elementary, middle school and high school — with school principals and an equal number of parents occupying seats.

The presidency of the board would rotate among principals and parents and would be on a serve-once volunteer basis to ensure fairness and limit undue influence over policy.

The benefits of this are direct and obvious: Millions of dollars in board members' salaries would be freed to go directly back into the schools themselves, parents would have a fair amount of control over their children's education, teachers would be allowed to teach, and, most importantly, the bureaucracy itself would cease to exist.

The one issue that would arise would be the managing of practical affairs of the system: school buses, janitorial services, utility costs, etc. But separating those affairs from the educational side of things would seem like a good idea, as well.

I have a large amount of respect for the work that school administrators and teachers do. In my experience the vast majority have been of the highest quality, with a distinct interest in providing the best education that they can.

We just need to allow them to do it.


Jeffrey R. Wilbur is a junior majoring in social science at Southern Utah University.

Recent comments

1) We don't have county school boards.
2) Until last year, salary...

Tom | March 10, 2008 at 12:29 a.m.

Six figure incomes for school board members? Perhaps some may earn...

MadMax | March 9, 2008 at 9:22 p.m.

I am pro Union and Pro Teacher. However I have heard indirectly that...

Open Letter to Teacher Unions | March 9, 2008 at 5:00 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Skateboarder stabbed at park

Whatever happened to curfews for kids? I'm not blaming the victim. But why do...

Obama, Biden, Reid, Pelosi, Barney the Frank, all....allllll.... all are...

TCU moves into 4th place in BCS

That is exactly what you zoobs were saying last year. Somehow, you think that...

Away in a manger

If you believe that God is the almighty then why worry about disbelievers? ...

@lesson one: I do not trust any politician of either party to tell the...

Becky Thomas: Find the cheese!

The article deals with the need to be flexible when crisis comes. The...

5A football: Darts edge PG

I just want to brag about something.....check out my prediction I posted on...

Jobless husbands help at home?

Though having the housework done is nice, it means much more to have my...

The only game that I have missed this year, due to my brother getting married...

What 3A team are we talking about? and what does that have to do with this year?

Advertisements
Advertisement