From Deseret News archives:

The 3rd time is (not usually) the charm

Old saying proved wrong in this year's prep basketball tournaments

Published: Tuesday, March 4, 2008 12:14 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The rhetoric can be heard and read every time it happens.

When two league rivals play each other in the postseason after one of them swept the regular-season series, fans, coaches, players and media types all say the same thing:

It's tough to beat a team three times in one season.

They'll say the team that previously lost twice to an opponent during the regular season now has some kind of advantage. They'll be motivated by revenge and their experiences in falling short will give them the answers on how to get over the hump this time.

But as this year's state basketball tournaments showed, maybe three-sweeps aren't all that difficult.

There were seven postseason basketball games involving matchups in which one team defeated an opponent twice during the regular season. Six teams that won twice during the regular season went on to win the third contest, and usually comfortably. The Manti boys team, the Class 2A champions, was the only two-time loser to win the third meeting against a team, as it defeated Richfield in the semifinals.

Story continues below
There was one instance of two teams playing for the fourth time in the 1A championship game and the result never changed. In that title contest, Escalante defeated Piute for the fourth time this season.

The three-time winners were the Judge boys (defeated Uintah and Wasatch), the Wasatch girls (beat Judge), the Mountain Crest boys (swept Woods Cross), the Timpview girls (defeated Springville) and the Piute girls (beat Panguitch).

"Back when we'd have our region tournaments, I used to hear all the time how hard it was to beat a team three times in a season," said Manti coach Mark Hugentobler. "My answer was always, 'That's not true.' Usually, when it happens (the two-time loser wins the third game) it makes headlines, so everyone hears about it."

Roger Pyper, who coached the Wasatch girls to the only unbeaten basketball season in the state this year, said high school basketball games are usually decided by talent and matchups. The Wasps defeated Judge Memorial in the championship game for the third time this season, in a game where the two teams' talent level wasn't all that different.

"Talent level is usually the difference whether you're playing for the third time or fifth time in a season," Pyper said.

The Wasps had an important advantage over the Bulldogs, as they were more experienced. Their players were older and were more accustomed to playing in big games.

Pyper said you also can't underestimate the confidence a team has when it plays an opponent after already defeating it twice in the same season.

Recent comments

LCA got beat by North Summit 4 times in one season

Anonymous | March 7, 2008 at 9:10 a.m.

I didn't post that Anonymous comment at 1:32. I know who beat who...

Anonymous | March 5, 2008 at 6:51 p.m.

I'm not attacking kids or coaches. I'm attacking you ridiculous,...

Anonymous | March 5, 2008 at 6:49 p.m.

Image

Judge High School basketball players celebrate beating Wasatch High in the 3A State Championship on Feb. 23 at the E Center.

previousnext

Latest comments

Lawyers earn fees from own laws

This smacks of conflict of interest and corruption. The fox is in the hen...

Stanford ends Y's soccer season

Maybe you should have started yanking their ponytails. Then you may have won.

Free markets and health care

What a superb op ed piece. As for the 'take personal responsibility' zealots...

SI curse will follow you after Collie appears in SI. Your woes againt UNM...

TCU 55, Utah 28

The conference is starting be respected. That is good. TCU has a great...

TCU is NOT the 2008 utah team! Not even CLOSE! No, they are MUCH BETTER than...

TCU creams U.

As a fan I have to admit that the beatdown Utah took last night was one of...

Jazz hope D-Will returns soon

Sorry Jaz4ever you need to get a grip....Locke is not awesome. It's tough to...

Know any RMs playing in the FBS?

Tulsa has 3 LDS players this year.

I know you BYU and Utah fans are on these boards sticking it too each other...

Advertisements
Advertisement