From Deseret News archives:
Smoot case fascinating
But there was an important difference: Roberts was a polygamist while Smoot was a monogamist, and the issue that surrounded each man was allegedly that of polygamy. Even though Utah Mormons today lean toward the Republican Party, the Republicans in Smoot's day were dead set against "the twin relics, slavery and polygamy."
The result was a long and bruising hearing led by Senate Republicans to expose Smoot as a secret polygamist, and thus send him home on the coattails of Roberts. The Senate failed in its carefully orchestrated effort, and Reed Smoot not only survived politically, he was a very powerful senator for 30 years.
For anyone attracted to Mormon history, the Smoot hearings represented a gold mine of testimony 42 witnesses in 17 days for and against his admission to the Senate. The documentation of the hearings has always seemed insurmountable with 3,432 pages recorded. Yet Michael Paulos, a young financial analyst who maintains a vigorous side interest in history, has produced a condensation that is slightly more than 700 pages.
His book, "The Mormon Church on Trial: Transcripts of the Reed Smoot Hearings," is not only carefully edited but deftly annotated, making this historic political and religious episode accessible and fascinating to the general public. Even as a BYU student, Paulos had become enamored of the Smoot hearings, although he found it difficult to understand them either from written history or from college classes.
So in 2001, he began his own research into the Smoot case, reading up on its background and collecting his own copy of the transcripts, working mostly evenings and Saturdays. "I'm a political junkie, and I love Mormon history," said Paulos during a phone interview from his home in San Antonio, "so the Smoot case seemed the perfect intersection of both. I was fascinated."
He found that the testimonies of Reed Smoot, LDS President Joseph F. Smith and Apostle James E. Talmage propelled Mormonism into the public square much as Mitt Romney's presidential candidacy did for modern Mormonism. "Smoot is part one, Romney is part two," Paulos said. The parallels between Smoot and Romney are pure serendipity."












