From Deseret News archives:

One in 4 bills poses a conflict

Jury still out on whether Capitol 'specialties' present a problem

Published: Sunday, Feb. 10, 2008 12:21 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
One of every four bills introduced in the current Legislature creates an apparent conflict of interest for sponsors, a Deseret Morning News review shows.

That is not too surprising since Utah's 104 lawmakers work only part time in the Legislature, but full time as lawyers, teachers, dentists, Realtors, developers and at other jobs. Many push bills in areas of their expertise — considered one of the pluses of a citizen lawmaking body. While that can take advantage of their knowledge, it can also make them power brokers and leaders in arcane areas of the law, or help their professions.

Take, for example, Rep. Lorie Fowlke, R-Orem, one of two members who had all the bills they introduced this year in an area where they work in their private lives. She is an attorney specializing in family law, and her bills ranged from protective order amendments to joint custody amendments and stalking amendments.

"What is scary is when you have people voting" on bills "they really know nothing about," she said. But Fowlke says that rarely happens in the Utah Legislature, where people from different backgrounds help each other understand issues in their areas of expertise.

Story continues below
The individual expertise that 104 legislators can bring to lawmaking is invaluable, she said. "It is really helpful that we have so many different professions up here" to lend their wisdom to lawmaking.

She says she saw a need for better law in her area of family legal issues. "My emphasis has always been to clarify the law," Fowlke said. "Good attorneys follow the law. If you agree on the law, then you may (only) go to court over the facts."

But others see conflicts as problems. Claire Geddes, who has watched the Legislature for years as a public advocate, says conflicts are "the number one ethical problem at the Legislature — and legislators just don't take it seriously at all."

Geddes says votes there rarely break along party lines, and, "Instead, the issues break out along self-interest lines. It is infamous that they pass bills that help their own industries," she said. "The public loses big-time, and everyone just acts like it is OK because we have a part-time Legislature. It is not OK."

The Deseret Morning News compared all bills introduced in the 2008 session with legislators' conflict of interest disclosure statements and their known hobbies, jobs or former jobs and the jobs and financial interests of their spouses and close family members.

Recent comments

Training Courses for Information Technology Equipment and Software. ,

Anonymous | Oct. 22, 2009 at 5:22 p.m.

Dan Eastman, former car dealer from Bountiful, sponsors many bills...

richard saunders | March 26, 2008 at 10:37 p.m.

I suggest that each of you do what I do after each election: go to...

Smeagle | Feb. 10, 2008 at 11:55 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Letters: Christian founders

The idea that anybody else but you is capable of interpreting the...

I miss the days with Malone, Stockton and Hornacek, those guys were injured,...

Not a pretty win, but way to and yet another win BYU. I love this team....

My prayers go to this family for the loss of their fine young son. God bless...

Seriously if you want to hear the arguments of Progressives it won't be on...

No. 22 BYU holds off pesky Lobos

Don't go out of your way or anything on reporting here. Four sentences is all...

re: So Sweet The REAL joy has returned. Utah has just tied it with TCU,...

No. 22 BYU holds off pesky Lobos

AF, WYO, and CSU are all ranked higher than the pathetic NM.

Even at the time of the Colonies, White Christian men who owned property were...

No. 22 BYU holds off pesky Lobos

BYU will most likely drop out of the the top 25 with this Junior high school...

Advertisements
Advertisement