From Deseret News archives:

KTVX faces FCC fine

Published: Wednesday, Jan. 30, 2008 12:23 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The Federal Communications Commission wants to fine KTVX-Ch. 4 $27,500 for an "NYPD Blue" episode that aired almost five years ago.

Actually, the FCC wants to fine 52 ABC owned and affiliated stations $27,500 each. That's a total of $1.43 million for all the ABC stations in the Central and Mountain time zones.

And, yes, it seems unfair to fine ONLY the stations in those two time zones.

The "Blue" episode, which aired on Feb. 25, 2003, featured a scene with Connie (Charlotte Ross) getting ready to take a shower and being surprised by Sipowicz's (Dennis Franz) young son. According to the FCC, the scene featured a shot "panning down her naked back for a lingering shot of her buttocks," which constituted "explicit and graphic depictions of sexual organs" that was "titillating and shocking."

I've been criticizing "NYPD Blue" for its unnecessary nudity since before the show premiered. (After I saw the pilot, of course.) And I'm certainly not going to defend it now.

But to suggest that seeing naked buttocks in the 10th season of "NYPD Blue" — the 210th episode of the series — was "shocking" is, well, ridiculous. It wasn't even mildly surprising.

(Maybe the episode's title — "Bottom's Up" — caught the FCC's attention.)

Story continues below
ABC is left to defend the scene by making unconvincing arguments about artistic integrity and how the scene was integral to the storyline about how it can be awkward for a single parent to bring a new person into his life. That, of course, is silly. The same thing could have been accomplished without the nudity.

Nudity always was nothing more than a ratings ploy on "NYPD Blue." A rather effective ploy, but it was never absolutely necessary to tell any story.

But the network's argument that the content of the show "was well known to the viewing public" after more than 200 episodes is irrefutable.

It might cost KTVX and 51 other stations $27,500 apiece, however. Even though the current owners didn't have anything to do with the station in 2003, they're still responsible for the fine (if ABC loses its appeal).

This incident predated congressional action that raised the amount stations could be fined to $325,000.

Why are two time zones being picked on? Because "Blue" aired at 9 p.m. Central and Mountain, not 10 p.m.

But, um, prime time has been 7-10 p.m. Central and Mountain — as opposed to 8-11 p.m. on the East and West coasts — more or less since TV began.

How did it just suddenly become a problem?

And then there's the sadly amusing statement from FCC Commissioner Deborah Taylor: "Our action today should serve as a reminder to all broadcasters that Congress and American families continue to be concerned about protecting children from harmful material and that the FCC will enforce the laws of the land vigilantly."

Um, isn't there some sort of time element inherent in being vigilant? If this is so egregious, how did it take 59 months to decide something had to be done?

If it took your landlord almost 5 years to deal with a dangerous situation, you probably wouldn't describe him as vigilant.

This is your government at work, folks.


E-mail: pierce@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Principal leaves giant imprint

Great job mom. Keep it up. By the way, what exactly is an equivalent?

Miss. teen follows mission

If you had read a little bit, you would see th subject is named Daniel....

I sure hope he's OK. What was he doing going out at 2 am on Black Friday?...

To Marriage and conflicts: While generally I agree with what you said, not...

Temple Square to use LEDs

The jingoistic American who commentated earlier clearly did not read the...

If "druggies" can be inducted into the Hall, then why not a gambler?

Hope it is not serious. Maybe he was on his way to Black Friday Shopping or...

How tragic! Will he be able to play? Will he die? Please tell the Tiger...

Cougs to host Weber St.

WSUfan, do you remember me? Yellow Books something? from a wildcat fan...

It's so wonderful I'm a fan, why can't you all appreciate the wildcats and...

Advertisements