From Deseret News archives:

Davis must pay fees in fluoridation lawsuit

Published: Sunday, Dec. 23, 2007 12:03 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The Utah Supreme Court has overturned a district court ruling and will require that the Davis County Clerk's Office pay attorney fees to a pro-fluoride group.

Utahns for Better Dental Health sued Davis County Clerk Steve Rawlings in 2002 after a revote on the 2000 approval of fluoridated water was placed on the ballot. They argued that the revote, which was requested by a petition from an anti-fluoride group, was a misinterpretation of the state's referendum law and should not be allowed on the ballot.

The district court ruled in favor of UFBDH but did not grant its request for attorney fees from the county. The group appealed to the Utah Court of Appeals, which ruled that the district court ruling failed to "justify" the decision and remanded the case back to the district court.

The district court, however, did not change its ruling but further clarified its original ruling, so the UFBDH appealed to the Utah Supreme Court.

Writing for the majority, Chief Justice Christine Durham wrote that the refusal to award attorney fees was "at odds with its original decision" about the referendum. Attorney fees can be awarded when the case serves a broader public interest, which Durham felt this case did.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

BYU would like friendlier rivalry

I don't know for certain, but I think the enrollment at the U is more like...

Read the article in USA TODAY. The national rating was 0.9.

Letters: Trump card for believers

2:41 p.m. Why would I care if there were a aymbol of Wican or Satanism or...

Dale the Chipmunk is a fictional character. So, who is the confused individual?

Letters: Time for health reform?

RE:RedShirt "To "1st Pagan | 1:15 p.m." Canadians say that their system is...

Real Salt Lake: Fandemonium

Check the article in USA Today. 0.9 was the national rating.

'I agree with your assessment of Chaffetz but I have to ask --- did he...

Letters: MLS not BCS

No, Dick. A winning season is defined as having won more than half your...

Expect epic clash on the line

On sunday morning the new catch phrase will be "..and Pitta is still open in...

Alternative to climate change?

Have none of you read the story about the global warming hoax being exposed?...

Advertisements