From Deseret News archives:

It's a game!

Published: Wednesday, Dec. 19, 2007 12:14 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
On Sunday, KUTV's Brian Mullahy, Katie Baker and Ty Perry provided an excellent lesson for aspiring broadcast journalists: If you don't know what you're talking about, don't talk.

On Ch. 2's 10 p.m. newscast, anchors Mullahy and Baker both expressed some degree of shock and surprise that Utahn Todd Herzog (gasp!) lied to fellow contestants en route to winning the million dollars on the hit CBS show "Survivor." Apparently, they've never seen the show — it's all about strategy and deception.

And it's a game!

Would you criticize a champion poker player for bluffing? Of course not.

All 15 winners have strategized, bluffed and, yes, lied. Even Neleh Dennis, the sweet-as-pie Utahn who finished second in Season 4, had to deceive people to get as far as she did.

And then KUTV hired her as an on-air personality.

So it was ridiculous to criticize Herzog for playing a game by rules that have been well established over the past seven years.

"He said himself that he lied as part of his strategy," Mullahy said, shaking his head.

Story continues below
"Ohhhh," Baker said, pulling faces and shaking her head. "And maybe he won't have trouble sleeping at night because he'll have very nice sheets to lay down on."

"I guess," Mullahy replied. "Some people may question the strategy, but all right."

Absolutely ridiculous.

I'm not suggesting that Mullahy and Baker be required to watch "Survivor." But don't sit in judgment on something you know nothing about.

And KUTV's audience would have been well-served had Perry done two minutes' worth of research before reporting on "Survivor." Talking about Herzog's reputation as a schemer on "Survivor," Perry said, "One survivor even called him slimy."

Actually, second-place finisher Courtney Yates called him "slippery." And there's a major difference between the two.

Perry also reported that, since returning from China in August, Herzog, "hasn't told a single soul that he was even involved with 'Survivor' or that he was the winner of 'Survivor.' So he has kept a big secret for quite a long time."

First, it's not true that Herzog didn't tell anyone he was involved with "Survivor." (He attended local viewing parties, for goodness sake.) And, second, Herzog couldn't have told anyone he was the winner because he didn't find that out until Sunday night.

I'm not suggesting "Survivor" was a huge story (although KUTV led its Sunday newscast with it). But if you're going to report on it, know what you're talking about.

Recent comments

Big "Survivor" fan here. I was hoping Amanda would win, frankly,...

Linda | Dec. 19, 2007 at 10:59 a.m.

Image

Todd Herzog

previousnext

Latest comments

Wouldn't this be a good way to get rid of the carp in Utah Lake? Provide some...

Temple Square to use LEDs

Unlike its general membership, the church is known worldwide for their love...

Wives of coaches are heroes

to two fine women with outstanding husbands and coaches. GO UTES!

Study: Foods slow shopping impulse

This may be true but it only works when grocery shopping. By Black Friday...

Economy showing signs of life

I hope some of our Utah state legislators are reading this report and maybe...

What a waste. I'm an American living and working with the rural poor in...

Girls basketball rankings

Next three years Syracuse girls state champs! Young and very talented!!!!!...

I'm sorry for the loss this man's family will experience. What was to be an...

Finally a president that does something constructive. Dave, stop telling...

I hope they get him out as soon as possible. What a horrible experience for...

Advertisements