From Deseret News archives:
Water suit sent to state court
Roosevelt is trying to add existing well to its culinary supply
On Nov. 28, Judge Tena Campbell rejected a motion by the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs to dismiss Roosevelt city's lawsuit against Utah State Engineer Jerry Olds. The city is suing Olds over his denial of a point-of-diversion application that would have allowed Roosevelt to add an existing but formerly unused well to its culinary water system.
Attorneys for the city and the state had opposed the BIA's motion to dismiss in federal court, which was filed under the umbrella of the Sovereign Immunity Act.
"What they (the BIA) were doing was using their sovereign immunity as a sword, when they were supposed to be using it as a shield," said David Wright, an attorney who represents Roosevelt.
While a dismissal of the case in federal court would have forever ended the suit against Olds, he did not approve of the BIA's methods, according to Assistant Utah Attorney General Norman Johnson.
"The state engineer believes de novo judicial review is part of the water rights application process," Johnson said. "Those aggrieved by his decisions are entitled to such review and that review should be in state court."
However, the BIA was never a target of the lawsuit and the Ute Indian Tribe was merely named as a "party of interest" in the suit against Olds because along with 31 individuals living in the Neola area the tribe had objected to the state issuing a permit to Roosevelt. The opposing parties alleged that the city's development of the well would harm other water users by draining the area's aquifer.
Johnson argued before Campbell that the Sovereign Immunity Act was only meant to shield foreign governments from being sued in federal courts, not as a tool for interfering with the actions of other agencies. He reasoned that the Ute Tribe can still sue in state court if it believes it would be harmed by Roosevelt's use of the Durigan Springs well.
Other federal agencies have successfully used the Sovereign Immunity Act many times in the past 30 years to block lawsuits affecting their interests, according to both Johnson and Wright.
Comments
- 65 leaders set for climate summit 9:36 a.m.
- Nevada grabs rushing records 9:34 a.m.
- RSL will play for MLS Cup tonight 3:06 a.m.
- Jazz outlast Pistons in overtime 3:06 a.m.
- Utah Utes whip SDSU 3:05 a.m.
- BYU records with win 3:05 a.m.
- RSL dancing with soccer stars 3:04 a.m.
- Cougars turn focus to dreaded rivals 3:04 a.m.
- Dixie State campus briefs 3:03 a.m.
- Weber State campus briefs 3:02 a.m.
- Glenn Beck to enter politics?
- BYU records with win
- Police link alcohol to murder
- Can BYU throw vs. Air Force?
- Huntsman blasts media over trip
- Christian leaders not backing down
- Memo out again tonight for Jazz
- Cougars cruise to victory in Hawaii
- Jazz outlast Pistons in overtime
- Nephi's steel bow difficult to replicate
- Buttars wants to limit gay rights laws
193 - Palin plans tour stop in Utah
173 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?
149 - Palin's book shows she's unqualified
122 - Officer cleared in Cardall Taser case
103 - BYU cuts Women's Research Inst.
100 - BYU records with win
99 - Jazz finally win in San Antonio
98 - Utes knock off rival Aggies
93 - Huntsman pleased with Obama
87
A little after midnight Wednesday morning, about 21 hours ago as I write...
There's a lot of reason to leave your plastic home as you shop:
It's so weird. A week before Thanksgiving and already the Xmas decorations...
We loved it! Thanks for the team effort. You overcame some unusual...
It was an Even with the glitches.
BYU can do better than those two. The defense stinks and the offense is to...
The three missing guys all stink. Forget them. AK and CB playing better....
When is Harpring going to announce his retirement? Did I just miss that news...
I hope there will be a public vote on this
I was working in a beauty salon, it as a Friday afternoon, in California. I...
Every time we go out to Wendover ( about once every three years) We go out...
I've never heard the BYU crowd boo the officials so strongly. Even after the...


You can be the first to comment on this story.