From Deseret News archives:

Money set aside for vouchers could go to education — or roads

Lawmakers to decide if $9.3 million stays in the general fund

Published: Sunday, Nov. 11, 2007 12:09 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
With Utah's voucher program dead, many hope the $9.3 million set aside by lawmakers will go to public schools.

But hard feelings and transportation needs could keep schools from seeing any of that cash.

Money for parents who choose to send kids to private schools was part of Utah's general fund, the big checkbook that pays for roads, social services and state workers. It wasn't part of the K-12 budget.

"Had we not funded the vouchers, we would have just left it in roads. I suspect what we'll do is put it back in the general fund for roads," said Sen. Lyle Hillyard, R-Logan, co-chair of the Appropriations Committee.

The money isn't going anywhere until lawmakers convene in January, but a bitter dispute over vouchers has convinced many that lawmakers have no intention of putting it into public schools.

"The only reason I think they funded it out of (the general fund) was so the argument could not be made that this was taking away from money to public education," said Roberta Herzberg, head of Utah State University's political science department.

Hillyard said the money could fill many needs, including employee salaries, social services and transportation for a rapidly growing state.

Story continues below
But Kirk Jowers, director of the Hinckley Institute of Politics at the University of Utah, said lawmakers might feel a backlash if the money goes anywhere other than education. The voucher law was rejected by 62 percent of voters Tuesday.

"With the size of the victory, it would really be seen as sour grapes" if this money doesn't go to public schools, Jowers said.

Gov. Jon Huntsman has said one of his top priorities is increasing teacher pay. He also said he wouldn't rule out using money from the general fund to pay for it.

The voucher program's sponsor, Rep. Stephen Urquhart, R-St. George, said he'd be willing to spend the money on public schools, but he wasn't sure in which way. He also noted that every lawmaker probably has ideas about how to spend it.

Kim Campbell, president of the teachers union, the Utah Education Association, had hoped the defeat of vouchers would be a clear signal to lawmakers that public schools need more money.

But the feeling among many legislators is that public educators, who were anti-voucher, are ungrateful for the $550 million increase they got last year, making new significant gains unlikely.

"I sense some frustration from legislators who constantly get beat up by the education community that we don't have education as a priority, when we know what a priority we have for it," Hillyard said.

Herzberg predicts the Capitol won't be a friendly place for public educators "for a while at least."

Recent comments

James- Your blame is in the wrong place. The office of education is...

News Reader | Nov. 12, 2007 at 10:49 p.m.

It is amazing that the majority of the public does not understand...

James | Nov. 12, 2007 at 7:46 a.m.

I had hoped the vouchers would become a reality in
Utah -- U.S.A....

A Hoosier | Nov. 12, 2007 at 7:18 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

can't erase basic genetics ================== Au contraire Human...

Letters: Reckless bill

You betcha'. Conservatives were against the perscription drug bill. Now...

Jazz players react to RSL title

As much as everyone likes watching free throws, I think the NBA should stick...

Best prep football games of 2009

OLY 28 Skyline 14 With East and West dropping their rivalry, the "Battle...

Fans - and that means everyone on this webpage - need to tone it down a...

day and age people still do this tripe?

@Red Shirt: I think it's pretty well established why Obama won the election:...

I wish the writer would have given an explanation as to why other research...

Bronco, Kyle rubber match

what makes me think we can win is David Reed running wild on your secondary...

BYU would like friendlier rivalry

U fans seem to defend the poor actions by other fans, while there are a few...

Advertisements