From Deseret News archives:

Don't count votes, west-siders urge

Court ruling sought on legality of balloting for school district split

Published: Wednesday, Oct. 3, 2007 12:12 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The city of Herriman's argument in the Jordan School District split debate sounds like an age-old philosophical question: If a tree falls with no one there, does it make a sound?

Except in this case, the question is: If a vote is cast and no one tallies it, does it really count?

City officials hope not. In a hearing at U.S. District Court Tuesday, an attorney representing the city asked Judge Ted Stewart to forbid Salt Lake County Clerk Sherrie Swensen from tallying east-side-only votes regarding the creation of a new school district on Nov. 6.

If everyone in the Jordan School District — including west-side residents — is not allowed to vote on the issue, the election would be unconstitutional, says attorney Blake Ostler, who represents the city of Herriman and individual voters in a federal lawsuit filed against Swensen and Lt. Gov. Gary Herbert.

"I'm not asking to stop the election," Ostler said. "I'm asking for the votes not to be counted. I'm asking for whatever relief will protect my clients' interest. That includes not counting the votes, not canvassing the votes, not having Gary Herbert ratifying the votes. Whatever will protect my clients' rights is what we're asking for."

Story continues below
Ostler said he would have asked the court to cancel the vote, but he said too many hours have already been spent programming voting machines and preparing absentee ballots. While reprogramming the machines would have been difficult and burdensome, Ostler said simply not counting the votes would be easy.

The brunt of Ostler's complaint centers around the argument that not allowing Herriman residents to vote on the new district on Nov. 6 would be a violation of the First Amendment and 14th Amendment because the city and its residents would be directly affected by the outcome of the vote. If the east-side cities in the Jordan School District — Sandy, Draper, Midvale, Cottonwood Heights and Alta — split off, the remaining cities would essentially have a new district, too, but without a choice, Ostler said.

Residents in the resulting Jordan School District should have a vote because they will have to pay higher taxes to balance out the loss of east-side residents and resources, Ostler said.

Under current Utah code, west-side residents are not allowed to vote in the election because the district split was initiated by east-side cities. As a justification for the law, representatives of Herbert, Swensen and the five east-side cities cited similarities between the district's situation and common de-annexation cases where only the annexing entity is allowed to vote on what happens to its area.

Recent comments

This isn't about who pays what! This is about giving parents more...

Missing the point! | Oct. 4, 2007 at 12:36 p.m.

It is amazing to me that this has become such a ridiculous East side...

amazed | Oct. 3, 2007 at 4:51 p.m.

I assume all those who are concerned that paying for someone else's...

Socialist? | Oct. 3, 2007 at 3:03 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

I didn't know they needed protection. I wouldn't have a problem hiring a gay...

" Ask anyone who uses these things and they will tell you they want to keep...

5A football: Bingham over Syracuse

I'm a Bingham fan to the core but have to think that if your boy plays the...

The Coaches play a big part in building a team, but the make spark comes from...

Wyoming writer amazed by BYU

You may want to take a line from Mendenhall and have more class, oh but he...

Paa - I can answer your question. As for proof, just as with any...

To FOR Fort Hood victims. Could you please put your remarks in context of...

Wasatch defense stifles Desert Hills

Forum, to call out people, or to mock and make fun of in St George because...

Were the soldiers at Ft. Hood constitutional rights violated by Major Nidal?

U. hopes to keep clicking

I don't disagree with much of what you say, but here's a question for you. ...

Advertisements
Advertisement