From Deseret News archives:

Take clear-eyed look at Iraq

Published: Wednesday, Sept. 12, 2007 12:37 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
For years, extreme right-wing groups exacerbated divisions in Congress by applying political pressure to the Republican majority. Now that Democrats are in control, the extreme left is flexing its muscle. If this keeps Congress from a realistic approach to the war in Iraq, the results could be devastating.

As a case in point, the left-wing Web site MoveOn.org had the audacity this week to refer in an ad to Gen. David Petraeus as "General Betray Us" and to say he would "cook the books" in his report to Congress in order to favor the Bush administration's line. That's the sort of personal attack that diminishes serious debate as it sullies the reputation of a man who has served his country with honor.

Contrary to this, Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan Crocker have been sincere and honest in their assessments of the situation in Iraq. The overall tone of their testimony has been a reinforcement of something the American people need to understand. There are no quick fixes, no easy ways to help the Iraqis overcome their own divisions and establish independent self-rule. That effort will need time and a huge continued investment of human and financial resources.

But to pull out now would result in a chaos and struggle that "will mean massive human suffering — well beyond what has already occurred within Iraq's border," Crocker said.

Story continues below
Those two realities must be the foundation for any future Iraq policy. Extremists tend to discount these and focus solely on the mistakes that led the United States to this point, which is counterproductive.

Fortunately, some on both sides of the aisle in Congress seem interested in real debate. Compromises are possible. Some Democrats, however, are feeling pressure from the extreme left to vote to cut funding for the war in order to force greater troop withdrawals.

If anything, resources need to be realigned to focus on new al-Qaida strongholds in Pakistan and Afghanistan. But Iraq should not be abandoned.

Extremists have played a role in American politics from the beginning, but this nation's leaders generally have been pushed toward the center by realities. We doubt that a Democratic president would support an irresponsible withdrawal simply because that president wouldn't want to be saddled with the blame for what would result.

It would help, however, if leaders from both major political parties would condemn extremist elements who are coarsening the national debate.

Recent comments

Iraq is such a political issue now that we will have to wait until...

Spanish Fork | Sept. 12, 2007 at 3:04 p.m.

Senator Chuck Hagel kept asking Patraeus, if we are buying time, time...

Lew Jeppson | Sept. 12, 2007 at 1:40 p.m.

We aren't leaving Iraq. Notice the the Dem candidates for Prexy are...

NCG | Sept. 12, 2007 at 12:20 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Coach Mitchell we all want to tell you how much we appreciate what you've...

This is not new, the church has always been for fair treatment of all...

This is good news, and I certainly don't begrudge the gays and lesbians...

I don't see what's shocking about this. It's the stance that the Church has...

Timpview/Mt.Crest winner 48 - Springville/Dixie winner 7.

Gays get Mormon support in SLC

Now if only LDS could be protected. I do not agree with special rights for...

Gays get Mormon support in SLC

When Elder Oaks stated to the world that a gay person in the church can do...

Where's 'Tag when Utah needs him?

actually do change the interior defense. They are not a lot of help on the...

Strategy over outcome in TCU-Utah

He knows TCU and Utah but with his player talents, he cannot win against...

This position makes sense legally and morally. I have no problem with it at all.

Advertisements
Advertisement