From Deseret News archives:

Safety expert: Collapses at Utah mine can be traced to overall mining plan

Published: Saturday, Aug. 18, 2007 12:31 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A national mine safety expert believes the two collapses at the Crandall Canyon Mine — one trapping six miners Aug. 6 and another killing three rescuers Thursday and injuring six others — were caused by "bumps" that resulted from the way operations were being conducted at the Huntington mine.

Mining bumps are pressure-shifting seismic events than can cause the walls, pillars, ceiling and even the floor of a mine to literally explode and disintegrate. They can cause deaths and injuries, and can result in cave-ins. Bumps accounted for 23 mining fatalities in Utah between 1894 and 1978, according to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.

These so-called bumps are not uncommon in mining. But they can be reduced with safe mining practices, said Robert Ferriter, director of the Mine Safety and Health Program at the Colorado School of Mines. And while an investigation ultimately will determine the cause, Ferriter told the Deseret Morning News on Friday he feels certain the bumps were caused by mining activity.

"In my opinion, based on the evidence and the way it's described, I think it definitely was a mining-induced bump," he said of the initial Aug. 6 collapse.

"I think it goes back to the mining plan. How much ground are you going to take out? How much coal are you going to leave to stabilize? What size are the pillars? Again, it's a design-type thing. You want to minimize those bumps as much as possible."

Story continues below
It is common mining practice to leave large pillars of underground rock untouched, in roughly a checkerboard pattern, so that the rock can support the weight of the mountain and prevent cave-ins, Ferriter said. In Utah, those pillars typically are about 80 feet by 80 feet. But leaving a larger pillar, such as 90 feet or as much as 120 feet, can reduce the chances that bumps will occur because "there is less stress," he said.

"Earthquakes happen naturally. Bumps are a coal-mining phenomenon," Ferriter said, adding that bumps are more severe in Utah mining because thick (as much as 300 feet), heavy beds of sandstone often exist above mining operations, placing a great deal of stress on the man-made caves beneath them.

"The other thing that happens there is when you load it up, you are pushing the pillars into the floor, also," he said. "When the stress is overburdening, it pushes it (the pillar) into the floor," which can cause the floor of the mine itself to explode.

Ferriter said it is his understanding that around the time of the Aug. 6 collapse, miners had been extracting coal from the pillars themselves.

Recent comments

I think if they cant get the men thats trapped in the mine out dead...

reddog | Aug. 21, 2007 at 1:25 p.m.

No means of communication..!!
That has turned this tragedy into a...

A Fault Finder | Aug. 18, 2007 at 9:03 p.m.

UNO. YOU ARE CORRECT. TAKE IF FROM A 36 YR VET. OF THE AUTO...

silversmith1947 | Aug. 18, 2007 at 8:07 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Darts vs. Miners glance

Bingham 35; Davis 24; Bingham had the ball driving and could have easily...

Climate-change debate heats up

YOu can keep believing in the climate change scam if you want. The rest...

Responses to miscellaneous people: "Ryan" at 7:18 is not me....

A 'twittologue' with Chaffetz

Does Chaffetz even know, we all need HEALTHCARE Reform's and healthcare. No...

the huge crowd at the reception when the Spazz won the NBA title!! ....cue...

As the great Homer Simpson once said. BOREIIIIIIIINNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGG!

To the right, nothing Obama does will make you happy. The fact that you are...

You are right on brother. American society failed big time now looks like...

How a seer stone helped in translation

The Old Testament is replete with references to the Urim & Thummim, which is...

Utah County balances budget

My property taxes INCREASED in 2009 over 2008. I was told by the Utah County...

Advertisements