From Deseret News archives:

UDOT official deems Utah's bridges 'safe'

94% are in good or fair condition

Published: Saturday, Aug. 18, 2007 12:31 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
LAYTON — The fatal bridge collapse in Minneapolis Aug. 1 has spurred Utah to take a look at its own 2,800 bridges, one of which has the same design as the one that collapsed, killing 11 people.

But that bridge, which crosses the Bear River to an electrical substation northeast of Tremonton, is rarely used and poses little danger, according to the Utah Department of Transportation.

The Utah Transportation Commission received a similar report on the rest of the state's bridges from James McMinimee, UDOT's director of project development.

"Our bridges are safe," he told the commission Friday during an update on the state's program for inspecting bridges.

The seven-member commission, appointed by the governor, serves as the programming board for UDOT.

McMinimee told the commission that to replace every bridge in the state would cost $8 billion to $9 billion.

That means the state is fortunate to have 94 percent of its bridges in good or fair condition.

And even though 6 percent of the state's bridges have a poor rating, they aren't in danger of failure or collapse, McMinimee said.

Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. ordered UDOT to begin an immediate inspection of the state's 200 most critical bridges shortly after the Minneapolis bridge collapsed into the Mississippi River.

Story continues below
Two bodies were recovered from the river Thursday, leaving two people unaccounted for. Crews work around the clock to remove debris from the site.

Following the collapse in Minneapolis, Butch Waidelich, a U.S. Federal Highway Administration official for Utah, said that, like Huntsman, he too was concerned about Utah's bridges.

But after asking a lot of questions, Waidelich said, he feels comfortable.

"I can honestly say Utah has an excellent inspection program," he said, noting that Utah inspectors get "up close and personal" with bridges they inspect.

"I have confidence that the bridges in this state are safe," he said.

After Huntsman ordered inspections for the 200 bridges, UDOT executive director John Njord expanded the inspection list to include those known as "fracture-critical" bridges.

Fracture-critical bridges are those that don't have redundancy, or backup features, built into them.

"If one element fails, the bridge has the possibility of failing in the manner the bridge in Minneapolis did," he said.

Utah has 100 such bridges, McMinimee said, adding that most of them are older bridges. About half are state-owned, and the other half are locally owned. When the state builds a bridge now, it includes redundancies so if one part fails, the whole bridge doesn't go down, he said.

Besides the governor's emergency inspection order, the department inspects all bridges over 20 feet every two years. If the bridge has a poor rating, it gets inspected every six months, McMinimee said.

Each inspector much check for 300 fields of data, which are compared to previous inspections. That way, the department can track a bridge's sufficiency and any deterioration, he said. That allows the department to project when a bridge should be slated for repair or replacement.

UDOT deputy director Carlos Braceras said he expects inspections for the governor's list of bridges to be complete in September. The 100 fracture-critical bridge inspections should be complete in October.


Contributing: Associated Press

E-mail: jdougherty@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

To Tab Uno, I distinctly remember one incident where The Church DID try to...

Letters: Reagan's role overstated

He just couldn't remember how he got there.

to see the Utah County all-stars get beat by a LEGITIMATE high school team...

Utility worker killed in Roosevelt

Cindy & Family, I too was extremely saddened to hear about Richard's death....

Now on to prosecute the rest of those men!!! Way to go, Texas!!!

get the health insurance, oR PAY THE TAX. NOT paying TAXES has always been...

Brewer? You are correct - that is actually Brewer biggest weakness - not his...

Letters: How good is health plan?

Class fear mongering. Grow up!

Saying that either Bingham or Alta will overlook Hunter is ridiculous in...

What a beautiful story and a beautiful girl. I hope that the family does not...

Advertisements
Advertisement