From Deseret News archives:

Bust school myths

Published: Thursday, July 19, 2007 12:41 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
One of the functions of a newspaper is to provide factual information to foster the debate of the day. That was the purpose of a recent Deseret Morning News report on myths surrounding east-side and west-side schools in the Granite and Jordan school districts. Veteran reporters Lee Davidson and Jennifer Toomer-Cook crunched school data to determine, among other things, differences — if any — in class sizes, education attainment of teachers and facilities east to west.

Their analysis busted some myths. For instance, class sizes are slightly smaller on Granite District's west side than the east side, due in part to Title I funds that low-income schools receive. In Jordan, the numbers are virtually equal.

The analysis also debunked a long-held myth that the west side has more behavior or crime problems at schools.

However, the report did confirm other long-held views that east-side schools employ teachers who have more experience and higher levels of education attainment. The data partially confirmed that there are more special programs for talented students on the east side of the respective school districts.

Interestingly, these are not all predictable trends. For instance, less experienced teachers may bring more enthusiasm and improved teaching techniques to the classroom. That can be an advantage over teachers who trot out the same lesson plans year to year.

Story continues below
While Granite District has more special programs on the east side, it takes a concerted effort to help transport students to make opportunities available to them. Jordan, meanwhile, is attempting to add more gifted-and-talented programs and an International Baccalaureate program on its west side to help shore up differences

The full report, "Mythbusting: Are the stereotypes about east-side and west-side schools really true" is a must-read for parents in both school districts as the respective movements to split the Granite and Jordan school districts gain momentum. A vote by the Salt Lake City Council whether to put these issues before voters could come as soon as July 31.

This report should help elevate the debate from emotional stereotypes to hard facts and numbers. The report helps to clarify areas in which the school districts have made progress in ensuring educational equity. It also points out areas where each school district could improve access to certain programs or student success in existing programs.

Whether it's the school voucher debate or the school district split discussion, the first casualty in public discourse about education issues often is the truth. "Mythbusting" can be considered one guide in centering the debate on reliable information and sound analysis. That's a far better recipe for good policymaking than raw emotion.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I have been a huge Wasatch fan over the last couple years but I have to put...

This is about 2009, not leap year. The thing about NCAAF is that unlike the...

It would be great to see Donny win! As has ben stated, his style, grace and...

What kind of music did he do?

Not mistakes. True he abused more than one child. But what it sounds like...

4A polls are missing two of the top teams! Missing Timpanogas and Woods...

To Anonymous. Sad statement when law enforcement is forced to expend their...

Girls basketball rankings

AF will be strong, but young. They will be in the top 6 or 7 but 5A is super...

Clyde's lucky to be alive.

Montana had its coldest October in 30 years.

Advertisements