From Deseret News archives:

Test drivers 85-plus yearly

Published: Saturday, June 23, 2007 12:05 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
No act of the Utah Legislature could conceivably salve the pain of the family of a man and his 5-year-old daughter who were struck and killed by an 86-year-old driver while the pair were walking through a crosswalk en route to the girl's Murray elementary school. But the Legislature could take steps to increase public safety by requiring drivers 85 and older to submit to yearly driving tests.

This group of drivers is more likely to cause accidents than even 16-year-old drivers, statistics say. That's significant considering that teen drivers cause a disproportionate number of accidents.

In the wake of the fatal auto-pedestrian accident in Murray, the mother and grandmother of the victims has asked state lawmakers to reconsider a previously rejected proposal to permit anonymous reporting to authorities of the names of drivers whose driving skills have deteriorated due to age.

At the time, we opposed the bill because families — not the government — should take the initiative to take car keys from aging and declining relatives. In most families it would be fairly easy to discern who made the call to the state driver license division.

Story continues below
However, lawmakers should not abandon this issue. A legitimate argument can be made for more stringent licensing requirements of Utahns 85 and older. A study by Carnegie Mellon University showed drivers 85 and older have a mile-for-mile fatality rate about three times higher on weekdays than teenagers have on weekends, according to recent press reports. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety attributes the higher accident rate to declining vision, motor skills and perception.

If older drivers whose skills are deteriorating know they will face annual driving tests, perhaps they would voluntarily give up their drivers' licenses. Perhaps such a requirement would give families a natural opening to have "the talk" with an elderly parent.

But as lawmakers institute such a requirement, they must take care not to leave seniors stranded. They need to be mindful of seniors statewide who will need transportation to shop, go to church or go to medical appointments. Perhaps lawmakers could target some surplus revenue to agencies that provide such transportation. It would seem a small price to pay for safer roads.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Utah, BYU are top choices

It would be nice too see three teams THRASH BYU back to back thus year. If...

Utah Jazz: Okur feeling better

What are the teams gonna do when jazz get healthy? I like this lineup dwill,...

The truth is that many people who harbor ill feelings toward the LDS church...

Correction: town hall meetings

Did Matheson really reach 100,000 voters, or were there duplications in the...

Jazz players react to RSL title

Obviously the NBA would never go to a format that would decide a game based...

First of all being a Osmond fan of many many years, then to know him and his...

All criminal acts are rooted in hate.

BYU would like friendlier rivalry

Oh my...the only thing that makes me upset about the BYU/Utah rivalry, from a...

Just curious how Snow Canyon with a .500 last season record gets ranked in...

Greenhouse gases hit record in '08

"You wonder why conservatives look stupid to us liberals? " Maybe it's...

Advertisements