From Deseret News archives:

Reader responses regarding "The Mormons" PBS series

Published: Thursday, May 3, 2007 12:10 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
As an active member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, I was extremely disappointed in the documentary about the church. Most of the historians portrayed the historical events as if they had been there and through a negative or anti perspective. The thought came that they are "ever learning, but never coming to an understanding of the truth." Not at any time did it portray what the church really is except in the cases where apostles or faithful were interviewed, yet the materials surrounding those tiny segments seemed to put an unrealistic and negative slant on the church! The spirit of the gospel of Jesus Christ was minimal, while the spirit of doubt and questioning was there in abundance - how disappointing! — no name

I was disappointed in the 2 part series "The Mormons". I was hoping for something that was less bias against the LDS church. While everything discussed was accurate as I understand it, I felt it always had a negative slant on the way it was presented.

I feel they spent way to much time on the Mountain Meadow Massacre and polygamy. For example they spent 6 minutes discussing the exodus west, with no discussion of the Mormon Battalion and it's influence on the history of the church. Yet they spent 16 minutes on the Mountain Meadows. Is there not some bias in that treatment?

In discussing polygamy, while President Hinckley firmly said there was no such thing as a fundamentalist Mormon the show repeatedly referred to the polygamy groups as such. And the interviews were totally with those who are NOT LDS defending their right to practice polygamy but not one interview with a person whose ancestor practiced this in the early church and who had tender feelings about it.

Story continues below
I felt there were many interviews with those who had chosen to leave the church for various reasons and who had bad feeling toward the LDS church. You don't think they had an axe to grind? Where is the counterbalance? For example the woman who had 8 great-grandmothers who walked across the plains and left the church because when she did a reenactment of a trek didn't have the same feelings her grandmothers recorded in their journals so it wasn't true. Well duh!! It wasn't even the same experience with the same fears and commitment level. Where was the interview with a practicing member who had done the same thing and felt closer and a better understanding of what they went through? Not bias—I don't think so!!

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Move over, Monopoly

If any board game should receive an award as game of the century, it would be...

My heart goes out to the Sneddon's. As a mother I would think this is one of...

Max Hall embarrased himself and BYU with his comments. Absolute lack of self...

Corroon a step closer to governor

Corroon has the courage to raise our taxes. We need massive tax increases....

I'm glad I live in a state where businesses believe in robust government that...

U. eyes bowl for redemption

I am a BYU fan but I will be rooting on the Utes to win their Bowl Game. Its...

Why is Florez putting quote marks around welfare and dole?

Well written and embracing lots of truths...the quotes sprinkled throughout...

is the only way to describe his comments. BYU has been good to Max. Free...

What Max's so called apology can never make amends for is that Max's tirade...

Advertisements