From Deseret News archives:

Reader responses regarding "The Mormons" PBS series

Published: Thursday, May 3, 2007 12:10 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
As a non-member living in Utah, I have only words of praise for the balanced look at the LDS Church's origins, history and spiritual components in KUED's two-part program, The Mormons. I feel it was particularly important to present, along with the early persecution of church members, the social and spiritual torment of those who, for any reason and under any circumstance, have left the church. As one interviewee put it, "there is a dichotomy about the church" (approx. quote) and in the end, more than one dichotomy was addressed which helped me learn and understand more of this young faith. I do have a question, though: I got the sense from the program that more outspoken women ;have been excommunicated than men, and I would like to find out if that is the case — maybe in the Friday night follow-up. Look forward. Thank you. — Susan Nyikos

I just wanted to give my opinion. Having watched both Monday on Tuesday, I felt it was a fair documentary piece. I personally felt that Monday's segment was a little bit more biased — or so it seemed — as the majority of the people interviewed were non-LDS scholars and historians trying to explain LDS history. In a documentary about religion, it is impossible to separate faith and the historic events. But Monday's segment attempted to explain polygamy and the pioneer exodus purely from an historic context, and it really needed additional LDS members or leaders to provide the insights regarding the faith that prompted such action.

However, I felt that Tuesday's segment was much more balanced, and I felt it was a very fair perspective. Had Monday's segment taken the same approach, I would have been happier with the piece overall. — Dustin Tate

Story continues below
On the whole, the attempt by the producers of this documentary to be fair and balanced was not accomplished. Choosing a homosexual male who had forsaken family and faith and an axe grinding, male bashing former member as the voice of dissent by "so called intellectuals" for commentary on core doctrine and beliefs of the LDS Church was very much like having Lenin comment on American democracy. You know where he is going and which way he is going to take you. You are familiar with the old tired commentary, complete with rhetoric intended to inflame and defame and you are surprised by none of it.

Respectfully submitted, — Jack Peck, Sandy, Utah

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Provo star leads Bulldogs to win

You just posted that comment bring up the fact that we haven't dominated in...

Hapring is not going to retire until the end of the year. If he did, he...

Max Hall issues apology

I also think Max should have shut his mouth and been a gracious winner. He...

10-year-old's 911 call saves mom

What a hero. My husband is a diabetic and we have taught our children how and...

Those of you who think this man, Mitchell, is just ok, and fine and dandy,...

Quality wins, bad losses for Utes

This year they have two seniors. It will be a rough year. Starting next...

Huckabee's seeming - actually certain - demise is made worse by the fact that...

Being a devout UTE fan, I doubt all Max's personal reasoning was true, but...

To Great News! No, Christ is NOT the reason for Christmas. As they always...

It really ticked me off when I buy a piece of furniture and find all those...

Advertisements