From Deseret News archives:

Splitting districts could be short-sighted

Published: Tuesday, May 1, 2007 12:08 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
When I read articles about potential splintering of the Granite and Jordan school districts, I flash on a lapel pin worn by a former state special-education director that said, "All means all." It nicely captures the philosophy behind public education.

Now some east-side communities are considering opting out of their respective school districts to form their own. A new study commissioned by leaders of Holladay, South Salt Lake and Salt Lake County found that opting out of the school district would mean more resources for fewer students in those east-side communities. Those who would remain in the Granite School District would very likely be saddled with higher taxes to cope with growth. As Taylorsville Mayor Russ Wall cautioned in a recent Deseret Morning News report, "There's nothing positive that can come out of this for the city of Taylorsville."

Worse, it grates against the historical purpose of public education, which is we're all in this thing together. It means that people in east-side neighborhoods help pay for school construction on the west side because that's where the growth is. It means everyone supports the program because today's students are our future leaders and work force. The benefits of a well-educated population are well-documented. All means all, indeed.

Story continues below
Could public schools be better? Of course. But the answer isn't opting out. It's better governance and meaningful parental involvement.

One of the most oft-heard arguments for opting out of the school district is more parental involvement and local control. I'd venture I've attended a few hundred school board meetings during my journalism career. People tend to ignore the vast majority of issues that come before boards of education. Even decisions that hit people where they live — sizable property tax increases — go unnoticed until the property tax notices arrive. How would this phenomenon change in a smaller school district?

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Tiger is so yesterday, I for one will find another young phenom to cheer on.

Did you catch that "public health threat"? That means we will take away your...

Who do you think funds the homeless shelters in SLC? Mormons give more...

@@anon 7:38: you, sir, have your head in the sand. Just a little...

If I am speaking with someone I know to be a Christian, then I say "Merry...

Ash, ash, ash, your arguments are pathetic. The first indication of this...

It is obvious, Mr. Benson, that there is one heck of a lot you do not...

Pitta doesn't win award

Probably should have won it last year. Proably should have won it this year....

Climate draft has gaping holes

Note to those who still think this movement has nothing to do with MONEY......

This case just has me stumped. If only I had somewhere to focus my...

Advertisements